“They were filled with a strawberry filling, and they were out-of-this-world good!!”

—gotprincess

“I just want 3D Doritos back. That’s all I want. I will trade memories of my childhood for the addicting airy cheesy puffy taste of 3D Doritos in my mouth again. I don’t need any of those Christmas memories, take them, and just give me the 3D Doritos.”

—cinnalyn

“Too many people slept on this peanut butter and cookie goodness, and you should all pay for that, because I crave them all the time.”

—jennifert68

“Can we PLEASE get Pizzarias back???? They tasted like friggin’ CHEESE PIZZA IN THE FORM OF A CHIP. Is there any other combo that’s better?”

—jessicarayc

“My absolute favorite! I can still taste them.”

—c42afd9158

“They were amaaaaazing.”

—staceypatonk

“YOGOS YOGOS YOGOS. Yogurt covered fruit balls that were freaking delicious. Looking up a picture of their packaging opens up a hidden memory that I’m not sure is even real, that I once tasted such amazing goodness during my childhood. Bring the Yogos back, guys. Just bring them back.”

—e45700d578

“My mouth is literally watering just thinking about them. We used to chop them into tiny bits to make them last longer.”

—amyk453e68492

“They were sooo good and I think about them too much. It’s so sad they were discontinued.”

—rukidding

“I feel like I’m one of the only people that likes these, but I want them back. They were basically cake-y Oreos!”

—madelynf487f41e0c

“Black Pepper Jack Doritos! They were in a black/gray bag and were amazing — the perfect amount of heat.”

—malmobaby

“We used to go there sometimes just for those.”

—amyrousep

“My kingdom for P.B. Crisps. I have tweeted, written letters, posted on the Planters Facebook page, signed petitions to get these things back in my mouth. I have tried for years to find any other peanut butter snack or dupe recipe and literally nothing comes close to those sweet crunchy little dudes. I miss them so much.”

—macktarv

“They had weird fruit-flavored jelly on the outside and ice cream on the inside. The way I peeled it like a banana made the whole thing so much more fun!”

—cngg805

“I feel like no one ever remembers these, but they’re the only discontinued food item that I still think about all the time. The little orange and strawberry bites with the chewy filling inside were so so good!”

—allisonkated

“There used the be these Timon and Pumba popsicles that had gummy bugs and goo inside. I forgot who made them, but they were so good!”

—sarahnlefevre

“They were my favorite. Damn Frito Lay taking good things away and discontinuing them!”

—jazminef4c31ce952

“They were like Cocoa or Fruity Pebbles but cinnamon-flavored, and they were GREAT. Fond memories of eating them at my grandparents’ house, and I still think about how good they were to this day.”

—wkj5512

“I think it might still be around in some places, but I haven’t seen them in years. They were my favorite. There’s a Halls Breezers flavor that tastes similar, but it still doesn’t compare to the candy of my childhood!”

—hihoambero

“It was like the Dairy Milk Caramel but the middle was gooey chocolate instead. I was obsessed with this stuff!”

—shannonr4b75dbb9d

“I used to stock up at Christmas time every year. And then one year they never came out…still sad about that.”

—t49e12a934

“Jell-O 123 with its magic separating layers. My mom would make it in parfait glasses and boy did I feel fancy.”

—ashleys4b5fbdc76

“They were ice cream bars on a stick shaped like Mickey Mouse’s head, complete with a face done in chocolate ice cream and with ears dipped in hard chocolate. We always called them ‘rat heads’ as a joke and they were AMAZING.”

—wonktacular

“They were around for a little while, but no one I talk to remembers them. I’m starting to think they were just an intense (and delicious) fever dream.”

—okaykaylyn

“They were shortbread cookies with a soft fudge center, and they were the best thing in my elementary school lunch box.”

—danieller4856e1619

“Butterfinger BB’s are a snack I desperately miss. They were bite-sized, round balls of Butterfinger, and they were insanely addictive!”

—mattyc3

“They never make these lists, but Carnation Breakfast Bars. The texture was like chocolate-covered peanut dust. I would take one over a Kudos Bar and Dunkaroos any day!”

—clairmonde

“They had a way better texture than the regular puffs and they were so satisfying to eat segment by segment. I miss them.”

—sahvana

“It was like Golden Grahams covered in chocolate with those little dehydrated marshmallows that come in hot cocoa packets.”

—patrickjh2