Get Even More Visitors To Your Blog, Upgrade To A Business Listing >>

Insider takes on a ‘four corners’ crisis

A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Oct 13, 2023 View in browser
 

By Kyle Duggan, Zi-Ann Lum and Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Kyle | Follow Politico Canada

Thanks for reading Ottawa Playbook.

In today's edition:

→ Playbook reached former Defense Minister PETER MACKAY and Independent Sen. PETER BOEHM on what it’s like dealing with a high-pressure mass evacuation halfway around the world.

→ The Supreme Court will rule on the constitutionality of the federal government’s environmental impact legislation.

→ Palestine’s Chief Representative MONA ABUAMARA tells us about her push to change Canada’s tune on Palestine’s bid for the International Criminal Court to investigate alleged war crimes.

DRIVING THE DAY

STEADY STREAM — A shocking week ends with tensions high and all eyes fixated on the Israel-Palestine conflict as Canada scrambles evacuation planes to pull Canadians out of the massive conflict zone.

— By the numbers: 128 people boarded the first plane to Athens. The second had 153 onboard when it was taxiing Thursday afternoon.

Officials listed another Canadian as missing, bringing the total to four.

— Still unclear: How many people will ultimately need to be airlifted out. How long the flights will go on for. How much it will cost. If Canada can reach the roughly 100 Canadians stranded in Gaza through the establishment of a humanitarian corridor.

A Global Affairs official described it as a “permissive environment,” meaning anyone left waiting for the next flight should be able to board one and won’t be left stranded.

So far, the flight logistics appear to be going well. Last time Canada mobilized relief flights like this in Sudan earlier this year, one of the planes broke down and another flight was scrubbed over gunfire.

— Info from the void: You could have missed it entirely, but GAC did hold a behind-the-scenes press conference not for attribution on Thursday, meaning the officials stay nameless.

That was something directly challenged by CP’s DYLAN ROBERTSON, who pushed back against the sudden anonymity the department granted itself: “I just want to urge your department to stop with the business of unattributed sources. You're all people who testified publicly yesterday … it's quite ridiculous and this contributes to mistrust and misinformation.”

LESSONS LEARNED — This is of course not the first time Ottawa has had to orchestrate something on this grand a scale.

Playbook got on the horn with former Foreign Minister PETER MACKAY and Independent Sen. PETER BOEHM, who both headed up the successful 2006 evacuation of 15,000 people from Lebanon, for some insider takes on what it’s like to organize something of this magnitude.

It was an early test for STEPHEN HARPER’s government, which had faced similar early criticisms about a slow response.

A crisis like this sets Ottawa into a frenzy, with many “four corners” meetings taking place that involve top officials from PMO, Privy Council, bureaucrats and ministerial staffers. Desk workers filled a 24/7 operations center at the Pearson building on Sussex Drive – some slept there on cots.

MacKay recalls war-room-like scenarios where his staff convened meetings with the defense minister, chief of defense staff, PMO, public safety and immigration — and a lot of late-night calls due to the time difference and need for negotiating.

“My deputy and my chief of staff and several others at the department were literally sleeping on our sofas, staying at the office 24/7,” he said.

Boehm, an assistant deputy minister at the time, called it an “all-out effort” that took place over several days that required close coordination with the Israel Defense Forces.

— Similar but different: That effort entailed dealing with a war zone and all its hazards as well as coordinating with the local military.

But there’s a much bigger war zone this time, and that means the government is “going to have to up its game,” MacKay said. “This to me appears to be a much bigger crisis and challenge.”

The two situations aren’t totally comparable. In 2006, conflict was focused along the Lebanon-Israeli border area, which allowed people to come dockside in Beirut and have ships depart from there. Israel had erected a port blockade.

Flash forward to now, the Canadian Forces have better air lift capacity.

Boehm said Ottawa had chartered aircraft and a lot of boats, including some from northern Cyprus, as other allies tried to do the same.

“I do recall making phone calls to Cyprus — and Peter MacKay and I still joke about it — just trying to get a ship: the Blue Dawn,” he said. “We eventually got it, and then the Australians phoned me and were quite upset because they were negotiating to get that ship as well. So, it comes down to inventory that's available, conditions on the ground and to a good degree of patience.”

— Better than Uber: Prime Minister Harper traveling through Cyprus at one point even took some people back on his plane.

— 4 big things:

→ Securing the big military planes was the first priority before getting into complicated contract negotiations: “The Canadian Forces have been pretty good in terms of making aircraft or equipment available when they can do it, but you can't turn this on a dime if it's on the other side of the planet,“ Boehm said.

→ Vet like crazy. It was sometimes very difficult to determine if a person was a Canadian citizen or not, Boehm said. If they didn't have a passport, they would be screened and issued an emergency passport that just covers the trip.

→ Get ready to handle people used to being pampered by the service industry. "Back in 2006, we had people actually asking for Air Canada points and business class,” Boehm said. “I was rather thunderstruck at the time."

Former Canadian diplomat RAMBOD BEHBOODI had a similar takeaway on an X thread defending criticisms of a slow response by Canada: how do officials deal with the unexpected, like people who refuse to board an Airbus and demand a Boeing or can’t “get on board without my morning coffee”?

→ Catastrophes like these reveal the “understated role” of Canada’s under-resourced armed forces, MacKay said. “It seems only when crisis strikes does it occur to Canadians how important that security that they provide really is in their daily lives.”

Did someone forward Ottawa Playbook your way? Click here to sign up for your own edition. It’s free!

For your radar


TODAY’S LUNCH SPECIAL IS NOISE — The Supreme Court will deliver its judgment today in a case that will decide the constitutionality of the federal government’s environmental impact legislation that affects proposed major projects in Canada.

— How we got here: The case found its way to the country’s top court after former Alberta premier JASON KENNEY referred the law to the Court of Appeal of Alberta. That court found the legislation unconstitutional because it “intrudes fatally” into provincial jurisdiction.

— Fundraising fodder: On the eve of the judgment, Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT’s office expressed confidence the Impact Assessment Act, formerly known as Bill C-69, is constitutional. Conservatives, however, have attacked the legislation as prohibitive to building pipelines, calling it a death knell for future fossil fuel projects.

Cue the na-na-I-told-you-so partisan games either way.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS


— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU is in private meetings in the National Capital Region.

— Deputy Prime Minister CHRYSTIA FREELAND is in Marrakech, Morocco, where she will attend the G20 Finance Ministers meeting before heading home to Toronto.

9:45 a.m. The Supreme Court of Canada will deliver its judgment on Attorney General of Canada v. Attorney General of Alberta, a case examining the constitutionality of the Impact Assessment Act.

11:30 a.m. Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT and Energy and Natural Resources Minister JONATHAN WILKINSON will hold a press conference to discuss the Supreme Court’s judgment in the Impact Assessment Act reference case.

11:30 a.m. (8:30 a.m. PT) Conservative Leader PIERRE POILIEVRE is in Vancouver and will hold a media availability.

12:20 p.m. Public Safety Minister DOMINIC LEBLANC and Justice Minister ARIF VIRANI hold a press conference to conclude a meeting with their provincial-territorial counterparts in Bromont, Quebec.

1 p.m. Government officials provide a technical briefing for the media about developments on the situation in Israel, the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.

1 p.m. (11 a.m. MT) Liberal MP BRENDAN HANLEY will be in Whitehorse, Yukon to make an announcement related to the government’s promise to plant 2 billion trees.

9:30 p.m. (6:30 p.m. PT) Poilievre hosts a rally in Vancouver.

HALLWAY CONVERSATION


RAMALLAH TO OTTAWA — Canada’s role in the Middle East is to get out of the way of Palestinian efforts to launch war crimes investigations, says MONA ABUAMARA, chief representative of the Palestinian General Delegation to Canada.

Abuamara told Playbook that since her arrival, she’s been pushing for Ottawa to ease up on its role in blocking Palestine’s bids to get the International Criminal Court and International Court of Justice to investigate alleged war crimes in Israel and Palestine.

“We want Canada to not treat Palestine as an exception to the protection of this international rules-based international order — and Israel as an exception to adhering to these rules and international law,” she told Playbook in an interview.

Abuamara arrived in Ottawa nearly two years ago from a posting in Cyprus to step into the role of the Palestinian General Delegation to Canada’s chief representative. She’s on her second Canadian posting after previously serving as a counsellor for 3.5 years in Ottawa.

— Different views: Israel’s Ambassador-designate IDDO MOED told Playbook on Tuesday that Palestinians’ lives “have been taken hostage by Hamas terror organizations for years.” Abuamara says that is “absolute fabrication."

“The transformation of events prove Israel did not in fact implement this brutal siege to prevent Hamas from attacking it,” Abuamara said.

The violence has left at least 1,200 Israelis dead, according to the Israel Defense Forces. More than 900 people have been killed in Gaza. An estimated 150 Israelis have been taken hostage by Hamas.

— Worsening situation: Israel increased airstrikes on the Gaza Strip after imposing a total blockade in response to deadly surprise attacks launched by Hamas last weekend. A total blockade means nothing goes in. No food, water, electricity or medical supplies.

Abuamara says the blockade exacerbates conditions in a Palestinian enclave that’s home to more than 2 million people, nearly half of whom are under the age of 18.

Water security is poor in Gaza. Ninety-seven percent of the water in Gaza is undrinkable, according to a 2021 report by the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, citing decaying infrastructure.

“Depriving Gazans of fundamental rights and needs, not to mention preventing sick people, especially children, from getting the health care that they need … have nothing to do with security and everything to do with oppression, domination and tyranny,” Abuamara said. “That blockade needs to be terminated. No excuses.”

WHO'S UP, WHO'S DOWN


Up: JEAN CHAREST’s spirits, closing a media scrum saying, “Thank you very much. I missed you all ... That’s not true.”

Down: DOUG FORD, after the RCMP opened a criminal probe into the Greenbelt deal.

MEDIA ROOM


— Post-secondary education analyst ALEX USHER making a guest appearance on PAUL WELLS’ Substack, raging against Canada’s abhorrence to making tough political choices: “Fundamentally, the problem is us.”

— Top of POLITICO this hour: Republicans fume as party tanks latest speaker pick.

— Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister GARY ANANDASANGAREE tells The Canadian Press the federal government could enter into treaties with Métis nations after the passage of a bill that affirms their right to self-governance.

— POLITICO’s ANNABELLE DICKSON looks at the interconnected relationships in British politics — with many journalists and politicians much closer than they appear.

— BILL CURRY in the Globe reporting News Media Canada asking the government to accommodate some of Google’s concerns on C-18.

— Fresh from the Economist: “The culture wars have come to Canada.”

— CP’s JEREMY SIMES reports Saskatchewan invoked the notwithstanding clause over its school pronoun bill.

— LEV GOLINKINreports in The Forward that Ottawa has given at least $2.2 million to groups that have championed the vets from the Nazi unit to which YAROSLAV HUNKA belonged.

— REZAUL LASKAR writes in Hindustan Times that India is digging its heels in on insisting “parity in diplomatic presence with Canada.”

— POLITICO’s MATTHEW KARNITSCHNIG writes from Berlin: The Israel-Hamas war exposed the EU’s irrelevance.

PROZONE


If you’re a subscriber, don’t miss our latest policy newsletter from ZI-ANN LUM and NICK TAYLOR-VAISEY: Canadians stuck in Gaza.

In other news for subscribers:

— U.S. Treasury imposes first sanctions for violation of Russian oil price cap.

— Baltic pipeline leak raises winter gas supply fears.

— Hamas hate videos make Elon Musk Europe’s digital enemy No.1.

— Major Japanese airline becomes the first to buy carbon credits.

— China's soft message on Hamas is part of a much bigger strategy.

Playbookers


Birthdays: The late HUGH SEGAL was born on this day in 1950.

HBD to Tory MP JOHN BARLOW, Liberal MP DARRELL SAMSON, Ontario’s government whip, ROSS ROMANO, SAJJID LAKHANI of Impact Public Affairs and TAUSHA MICHAUD of McMillan Vantage. A special HBD to Playbook reader/bagel boss BRYCE TAYLOR-VAISEY.

Saturday celebrations: SHEMAR HACKETT of McMillan Vantage.

On Sunday: Liberal cabmin CARLA QUALTROUGH and former MP HAROLD ALBRECHT.

Send birthdays to [email protected] .

Spotted: Canada’s embassy in Washington, illuminated in white and blue.

MARIA BRICENO at PolitiFact weighing in with a pants-on-fire verdict for the Trudeau too-much-cocaine-on-the-plane myth.DAVID HERLE, now hosting leadership debates.

A smoky West Block.

Movers and shakers: JOAN MARIE AYLWARD appointed by the prime minister as the next lieutenant governor of Newfoundland and Labrador.

The Canadian Senators Group re-elected Sens. SCOTT TANNAS as their leader, now flanked by Deputy Leader REBECCA PATTERSON, returning Liaison PERCY DOWNE and new Chair GIGI OSLER. They’ll serve on a two-year term, replacing DENNIS PATTERSON and ROB BLACK.

Global Public Affairs vice-chair and former NDP premier DARRELL DEXTER is lobbying on behalf of Nova Scotia-based Full Circle Environmental Solutions, which wants "funding and resources that further innovate environmental technology in the waste tire recycling sector."

Media mentions: POLITICO has announced plans to launch its flagship product, Playbook, in Berlin early in 2024. GORDON REPINSKI will lead the Berlin Playbook team. You can sign up to receive the newsletter — in German — here.

TRIVIA


Thursday’s answer: MADELEINE PARENT, SIMONNE MONET-CHARTRAND and LÉA ROBACK were recognized for their influence on women’s and workers’ rights in Quebec.

Props to: HÉLÈNE CHEVALIER, MATTHEW DUBÉ, GEORGE SCHOENHOFER, DARRYL DAMUDE, ETHEL FORESTER, DOUG RICE, ROBERT.MCDOUGALL, PATRICK ST-JACQUES, and JOHN ECKER

Today’s question: On this date in 1957, Queen Elizabeth II made a live, televised address. Tell us two things that were significant about the event.

Send your answer to [email protected]

Think you have a harder trivia question? Send us your best .

Want to grab the attention of movers and shakers on Parliament Hill? Want your brand in front of a key audience of Ottawa influencers? Playbook can help. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: [email protected]

Playbook wouldn’t happen without: POLITICO Canada editor Sue Allan, editor Emma Anderson and Luiza Ch. Savage.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Kyle Duggan @Kyle_Duggan

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

 

To change your alert settings, please log in at



This post first appeared on Test Sandbox Updates, please read the originial post: here

Share the post

Insider takes on a ‘four corners’ crisis

×

Subscribe to Test Sandbox Updates

Get updates delivered right to your inbox!

Thank you for your subscription

×