In early April 2015, Mike had taken a trip down to Jen’s old Uni by himself as he needed to see Lisa. Other than the fact they rarely got to see each other, things were going well between them (although I’m sure from the title of the post you can guess how things end up), but recent developments had made it obvious that they would have to make a choice…

Lisa had been applying for jobs for after graduation and had been looking for jobs up around where we live (as the plan was always that she would join us and Mike would increase his harem by one). She hadn’t had much luck in finding anything suitable, which given the state of the job market wasn’t too surprising and we were perfectly prepared to take her in and let her live with us. Mike and Lisa had really been looking forward to this as it would mean they would finally get to be together all the time – although we had realised there would be a few technical difficulties as Mike, Jen and I would no longer be able to all sleep together without leaving Lisa out (we had a bed big enough for three, but four would be too much of a squash). (Note by ‘sleep together’, I am actually talking about sleeping – we were all more than happy to have group sessions with the four of us!).

Lisa met up with Mike at the station and they had their customary kiss (including him reaching under her skirt to fondle her). He commented on how smooth her pussy felt and Lisa told him Amber had shaved her just that morning so Mike teased Lisa and said he’d have to thank Amber properly (but which Lisa knew full well he meant ‘make Amber cum’). Mike promised Lisa she would get the bulk of his attention and pointed out that Lisa got to benefit from having both him and Amber play with her at the same time. Lisa agreed with this but said she still wanted a chance to have him to herself before sharing him with Amber and Mike told her he couldn’t wait to get home so he could hold, strip, admire, kiss, stroke and caress, lick, finger, eat and fuck her until she’d cum at least three times. With each of the words in the previous sentence, Mike slid his fingers along Lisa’s pussy and she moaned back at him – not caring that they were standing in a busy train station (she had a long enough coat on to hide what his hands were doing). She said she wanted to go home straight away so she could feel him inside her and despite their plan to stop off and have a drink and chat before fucking, they went straight back to Lisa’s place, to her bedroom and to the bed.

Lisa released Mike’s cock and rubbed it against her face, then gave him a strong, wet suck. She told him again that she wanted him inside her and Mike said he wanted to eat her before fucking her. As a compromise, she agreed to briefly 69 with him so he could taste her and they then fucked with Lisa riding up and down on his cock as he massaged her breasts or pulled her to him so they could kiss and he kneaded her ass. As Mike wasn’t intending to cum, Lisa ground her clit against him and humped back in forth with rapid little movements. As she got closer to cumming, Mike held her face just in front of his and told her to keep looking at him. They continued to fuck and hump against each other as Lisa’s orgasm built and Mike reminded her a few times to keep looking directly into his eyes. Lisa asked if he loved her and he told her she knew he did so she asked him to tell her. Mike stared directly into Lisa’s eyes and told her he loved her deeply. She panted out an ‘I love you too’ just before she came and pushed against him a few more times as Mike pressed hard into her. Lisa lay down on him, her head beside his and Mike told her again that he loved her. Lisa knew why he was there and told him again that she loved him, then said she didn’t want to talk about things yet and that it was up to him to distract her. When she lifted her head to look at him, she already had a few tears in her eyes so they kissed and Mike caressed her back and ass, occasionally tickling her gently. Lisa whispered that he could have a proper look at her pussy now if he wanted and Mike told her she might not get him away from it once he started. Lisa pointed out that he hadn’t cum yet so she was sure she’d find a way to convince him to get back inside her and rolled off him, pulled a pillow down and pushed it under her ass.

Mike commented on how amazing she was as he crawled down the bed. He spent a little while just admiring her pussy, gently stroking and spreading the lips and he asked her if he could take a few pictures as it was so well shaved. Lisa said he could but pointed out that he had literally hundreds of pictures and videos of her already – Mike said he could never have too many and grabbed his phone and shot some close-ups of her pussy, then asked her to spread her lips and finger herself and he then got some longer shots – including whole body ones. He didn’t spend long doing this though as he really wanted to get his tongue back inside her and he discarded the phone and scooted back between her legs and started kissing around her pussy. He deliberately tickled her with his tongue and she squirmed and told him not to tease her. Mike asked what she meant and she said he knew but he feigned innocence until she told him she wanted him to eat her pussy. Mike slid his tongue between her lips and lapped up and down a number of times from the entrance to her vagina to her clit and back. He asked if that was what she wanted and Lisa let out a low moan and said it felt good so Mike stopped teasing and went back to eating her. He didn’t try to hurry things along too much, but at the same time he didn’t try to draw things out either and ate Lisa straight to another orgasm. She was a little surprised about this as he’d usually back off at least once but he pointed out she had said not to tease and she said she wasn’t complaining.

Lisa said she’d had a reasonably strong orgasm so needed a little break and Mike started kitty kissing her but she then said she wanted to see his cock so they went back to 69ing, with Mike still kitty kissing her and Lisa stroking, licking, kissing and sucking his cock. As her desire built again, she started sucking him much more forcefully and in return, Mike swirled his tongue as far into her as he could and sucked on her clit. Mike would have happily eaten her to another orgasm, but Lisa wanted to make him cum inside her so she lifted her pussy from his face (despite him trying to pull her back to his mouth), turned around and impaled herself on his cock. Mike told her she felt very wet and she told him it was now his job to make her much wetter. She ground her clit against him again, but this time rode him with long strokes as well, pushing down hard on his cock so he went deep into her. They changed position so Mike was on top and Lisa wrapped her legs around him, pulling him against her as he pumped in to her and they then switched again to spooning with Lisa twisting her head round to kiss Mike as he fucked her, caressed one of her breasts and frigged her clit. He told her he wanted her to cum and she said she was close and that she really wanted him to cum. Mike told her there was no danger of him not cumming and as Lisa started cumming he told her he was about to pump his cum deep into her little cunt. Between gasps, she told him to go ahead and fill her and he obliged her – beginning to cum just at the end of her orgasm. Lisa pushed back even harder against him and said she wanted his cum as deep inside her as he could get it. Mike emptied his cum into her and she remained pressed against him, kissed him deeply and then lay her head down beside his.

They remained pressed firmly together with Mike’s cock still buried deep in Lisa’s cunt and Mike hugged her tightly for a couple of minutes until he felt her ease off slightly. When Lisa looked up, she quickly said that she still didn’t want to talk about things yet. Mike didn’t really want to talk about them either but was trying to be sensible and said that they would have to discuss matters at some point, but that he was happy to wait. Lisa lifted herself off of Mike and let his cum drip out of her onto his cock. Mike told her he had been saving his cum for her (which he had – he hadn’t cum in me or Jen for three days) and Lisa said she was thankful as she smeared it around his crotch and her pussy. Mike asked if she wanted him to clean her up (by which he meant kitty kissing her – inevitably leading to eating her again) but Lisa said that Amber could take care of that later on, as well as sucking his cock clean of their juices. Mike tickled Lisa and told her she was such a naughty girl getting her girlfriend to suck his cum out of her and that maybe he’d fuck her ass while Amber was eating her. At this, Lisa said it was probably time to meet up with Amber so they climbed out of bed and got dressed. Lisa pulled on a pair of white panties and said it was to keep her pussy moist and covered with Mike’s cum, but that she’d go without them if he preferred. Mike said he thought they looked nice and nuzzled the crotch for a little while until Lisa said he would end up distracting her if he kept going. In return for what he’d just done, she took the head of his cock in her mouth and sucked it clean, swirling her tongue around it and then releasing it saying Amber could take care of cleaning the rest, or that he could just push into her and coat the inside of her cunt with his cum as he fucked her.

Mike and Lisa met up with Amber and they went out for dinner and then a few drinks together. Mike greeted Amber almost as enthusiastically as he had done with Lisa, although wasn’t able to get his hands under her skirt at first though as she didn’t have a jacket on to hide what he was doing. It was only after dinner when they were on their way to a bar that Mike pull Amber up against a wall, slipped his hands into her coat and asked her if she was as well shaved as Lisa (he had already complimented Amber over dinner on the job she’d done shaving Lisa). Amber said he’d have to wait and see but Mike slid his hands down her back, over her ass and up under her skirt. Amber looked around to see if anyone was paying attention as Mike's hands cupped her ass and he expressed his disappointment that she had panties on. Amber said that not everyone could be as much of an exhibitionist as his wife was and Mike reminded her that she had openly been fingered, eaten, fucked and cum at the hardcore club multiple times and Amber gave him a coy look and said it was different there. Mike slid his hands into her panties and caressed her ass but when he tried to move his fingers to her pussy she reminded him that she’d said he would have to wait to find out if she was shaved. She pressed her crotch against his and told him she hoped he could manage a second fuck (knowing that he and Lisa had already had a session) and Mike assured her he could, providing of course he was allowed to eat her first. Amber said she wouldn’t expect anything less and pulled away from him as his fingers were still probing towards her pussy.

On the way back to Lisa’s place, Mike asked Amber if she would help make Lisa cum again. This resulted in Lisa being stroked, fingered, stripped of her panties and licked in various alleyways – mostly in complete privacy, but twice they were seen. Lisa didn’t care and the second time she even lifted her skirt to allow her audience to watch as Amber’s fingers rubbed Lisa’s pussy and then pushed into her. Lisa gave at least a little in return and rubbed Amber through her panties, as well as asking Mike for his cock and kneeling to give him a brief suck (mostly to make it difficult for him to walk the rest of the way). In Lisa’s room, Mike and Lisa turned on Amber and despite her protests that she was meant to be helping make Lisa cum, she was subjected to being fingered and eaten. Mike was allowed to pull Amber’s panties down so he could finally get to see how well shaved she was and he was delighted to see that she was every bit as smooth as Lisa. He buried his tongue in her pussy and commented (favourably) on her taste, eating her for a couple of minutes before letting Lisa take over. Mike asked Lisa if they should double team her and Amber said he didn’t have to do that, but Mike ignored her, spread her ass cheeks and attacked her ass with his tongue. Amber squealed and Mike asked if she wanted them to stop but she told them it felt good and to keep going so they did until she came. As she recovered, Amber asked what had happened to the plan to gang up on Lisa and Mike said he thought it was only fair she get to cum first so she could partially catch up with them. Mike spooned behind Amber, rubbing his cock against her ass cheeks and told her it wouldn’t be her last orgasm of the night, but if she was ready they could get back to the first plan and fuck Lisa senseless.

Amber was indeed ready and Lisa was toyed with for about an hour. Mike fucked her (without him cumming), he and Amber ate, fingered and used toys on her, Amber 69ed with Lisa while Mike fucked Amber (to give Amber another orgasm) and they double teamed Lisa the way they had done with Amber – with each of them taking a turn at each of Lisa’s holes. They got a further three orgasms out of Amber, which was enough to exhaust her so Mike told her he would finish off in Amber – banking on the fact that Lisa wouldn’t want him to cum in Amber. He was right – although Lisa did allow him to semi-fuck Amber for a reasonable amount of time until she climbed out of bed and slipped on Mike’s favourite pair of long socks and said she wanted his cock. Lisa rode Mike but Amber wasn’t abandoned and Mike ate her (giving her a third orgasm for the night) with Mike then fucking Lisa while Amber helped out with a little breast play and frigging Lisa’s clit. Lisa told him to cum in her as she came and Mike said that wasn’t fair as she had both him and Amber stimulating her so she’d cum much quicker. Lisa told him she was sure he’d be able to find some way to arouse himself while in bed with two undergraduates and squeezed her cunt around his cock. Mike said he’d do his best and pumped into Lisa with long strokes, already feeling his orgasm building and telling her he could probably cum in her beautiful, hot, wet, tight and young cunt whenever she wanted to cum. Lisa wanted to cum, but asked them to draw it out just a little longer so they did, pushing her close to orgasm and then Amber backing off on the frigging so Lisa could enjoy him sliding in and out of her. They kept her like this for long enough that she was begging to cum and Amber got Lisa to plead for her fingers on her clit and for Mike to push deep into her and cum. Mike shared a kiss with Amber and said he couldn’t hold back much longer anyway so Amber resumed frigging Lisa’s clit and the three of them shared a kiss as Lisa started cumming and Mike pushed deep into her and moaned that he was cumming too.

Mike remained on top of Lisa and kept his cock inside her as the three of them kissed more. Mike told Amber he’d love to see her in some long socks as well and she called him weird so he pouted and she said she’d do it in the morning. She then hesitated and asked if they wanted her to go so they could spend the night together but both Mike and Lisa told Amber they wanted her there and Mike added that she wasn’t allowed to leave. Mike and Lisa discussed a punishment for Amber even having suggested this and he suggested she be sent down to the kitchen to get them all something to drink, but that she would have to go naked. Amber didn’t like this idea as even though the kitchen wasn’t far from Lisa’s room, there was a reasonable chance she would be spotted. Mike made it as far as wrapping his arm around Amber and saying he’d carry her out the door if Lisa opened it, but Lisa couldn’t be bothered moving so Amber was let off.

Mike spooned with Lisa (not inside her, just pressed up against her back) and Lisa spooned against Amber as they fell asleep. In the middle of the night, Mike woke up and pressed against Lisa until he was hard. She stirred as she felt him rub against her and he whispered to her and asked if she wanted him inside her. Lisa replied ‘always’ and reached down to spread her lips and guide him in. They didn’t fuck, just slowly pressed against each other until they fell asleep again and when Mike woke in the morning he was hard again and instead of going down on Lisa, he rubbed her pussy until she was wet enough for him to slid in once more and he pushed deep into her. As they moved against each other, Amber woke up and told them they were as bad as teenagers so Mike pulled out of Lisa and crawled down under the covers so he could take turns licking both Amber and Lisa. Mike convinced Amber to put on the socks she had promised to wear and he then made Lisa cum (still just eating her), briefly spooned with Amber and then ate Amber to orgasm as Lisa kissed her.

Amber was quite prepared to help Mike cum (he didn’t have the same relationship with Amber as he did with Lisa, but they liked each other immensely as they shared Lisa’s affections) but Mike said he wanted a session with just Lisa. He didn’t say the words, but it was obvious that he meant ‘a final session’ and Amber was considerate enough to say that she had a stack of work to do. Before she left she told them to give her a call when they were done (expecting to have to console Lisa) and she left. As soon as Amber was gone, Lisa told Mike not to say anything yet and to just fuck her properly. Mike held Lisa, his still hard cock pressing against his stomach and asked her what ‘properly’ meant. Lisa said she was sure he could figure it out and Mike reached down to caress her ass and upper legs and pointed out that Lisa hadn’t put the socks back on. She sat on the edge of the bed and made a show of sliding them up her legs, lifting each leg in turn to slightly spread her pussy and then smoothing the material with her hands. When they were both on, she lifted her legs so her feet were on the bed, either side of her and asked Mike if this was better. In response, he knelt by the bed and kissed her inner thighs, placing a few kisses on her pussy each time he moved from leg to leg. Lisa said that this wasn’t ‘fucking’ and Mike said if she wanted it done ‘properly’, he’d need to give her pussy the attention it desired first, but gave her his word that he’d fuck her more than once and give her as much of his cum as he could.

They spent the next three hours playing. Mike didn’t even count the number of times he made Lisa cum, but he ate, fingered, frigged, fucked (without him cumming), rimmed and 69ed with her (still without him cumming). He teased her a few times – keeping her close to cumming for a fair while before giving her a release, then kitty kissing to prepare her for the next orgasm. They finished off with him fucking her as promised, her riding him, him spooning her, him on top of her with her faced down, missionary (with her legs wrapped around him), him kneeling with her legs up against his chest and finishing with Lisa on top and Mike pumping into her fast and hard. While Lisa is now quite experienced at cumming many times, this had still been a fairly intense session for her (even without the emotional implications) and her pussy felt quite sensitive so she could feel a fair amount as they fucked. She repeatedly told him to cum and as her orgasm hit she kissed him passionately, pushing her tongue into his mouth and kept her lips locked against his. Mike pumped away inside her and considered trying to hold back so they could extend the session longer, but he knew they had to talk at some point (and he really wanted to cum) so after a little while he pulled Lisa hard against him as he felt his cock pulse and squirt his cum into her cunt.