The search for the next Bachelor star is gradually shaping up as more names get taken into consideration, including Bachelorette runner-up Peter Kraus, Bachelor season 20 star Ben Higgins, as well as Bachelor in Paradise stars Dean Ulgert and Wells Adams. Unfortunately, there's something hampering all these names. Peter and Ben are not ready to get hitched, Dean has messed up in Paradise enough to lose his chance to hand out roses next season while Wells might be in a relationship with Danielle Maltby. But there's one more contender for the coveted position who might just unexpectedly fill the spot.