Craving a taste of paradise? Look no further than Maui, HI, where we've embarked on a mouthwatering quest to uncover the best Pizza on the island.

From cozy wood-fired pizzerias to lively sports bars, each spot offers its own charm and flavor. Whether you're a fan of traditional Margherita or prefer a Hawaiian-style pizza with a drizzle of honey, we've got you covered.

Join us on this delicious journey and prepare to tantalize your taste buds with Maui's finest pizza.

Key Takeaways

• Flatbread Company offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with a romantic ambiance, and their best pizza is the Maui Wowie with macadamia nut pesto and pineapple.
• Pizza Madness Maui is a casual, local pizzeria with cozy interiors and wood-fired pizzas. Their specialty pizza is the Maui Madness with bacon and pineapple.
• Lahaina Pizza Company is a casual restaurant with ocean views and island-style charm. Their must-try pizza is the Local Pie with Maui-sourced ingredients.
• Prison St Pizza is a lively and rustic family-owned pizzeria known for their huge portions of delicious pizza. They also offer local island beers and a signature pizza with generous toppings.

Flatbread Company

We have heard that Flatbread Company is known for their delicious pizzas with unique toppings. Located in Maui, HI, Flatbread Company offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with natural wood accents and bamboo furnishings. The open kitchen allows customers to watch their meals being prepared, adding to the experience. The restaurant has a romantic ambiance, with dim lighting and light music playing in the background.

When it comes to safety, Flatbread Company takes it seriously. The staff ensures that all safety protocols are followed, from food handling to cleanliness. The restaurant maintains a high standard of hygiene, ensuring that all surfaces and utensils are regularly sanitized.

One of the standout pizzas at Flatbread Company is the Maui Wowie, topped with macadamia nut pesto and pineapple. This unique combination of flavors creates a truly memorable pizza experience. The ingredients used are sourced locally, ensuring freshness and quality.

Whether you're a local or a visitor to Maui, Flatbread Company is a must-visit for pizza lovers. With their delicious pizzas, warm atmosphere, and commitment to safety, it's no wonder they're highly regarded in the area.

Pizza Madness Maui

Let's try the specialty pizza, Maui Madness, at Pizza Madness Maui for a taste of bacon and pineapple madness. This local pizzeria, established in 2005, offers a cozy atmosphere with low ambient lighting, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a sunset at the nearby beach.

The wood-fired pizzas at Pizza Madness Maui are known for their perfect char and gooey cheese, creating a delightful combination of flavors.

Here are four reasons why you should give Pizza Madness Maui a try:

• Fresh Ingredients: Pizza Madness Maui uses only the freshest ingredients in their pizzas, ensuring a high-quality and delicious dining experience.
• Local Charm: This casual pizzeria embodies the laid-back and friendly spirit of Maui, making it a welcoming place for both locals and tourists alike.
• Attention to Detail: The wood-fired pizzas at Pizza Madness Maui are carefully crafted, with each pizza receiving the perfect amount of toppings and cheese for a satisfying bite.
• Cozy Atmosphere: With its cozy interiors and low lighting, Pizza Madness Maui provides a comfortable and relaxed environment, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends and family.

Lahaina Pizza Company

One of the top pizzerias in Lahaina is Lahaina Pizza Company. Established in 1994 by Jerry Kunitomo, this restaurant offers a variety of delicious pizzas with locally sourced ingredients. With its casual atmosphere and ocean views, Lahaina Pizza Company provides a safe and enjoyable dining experience for pizza lovers. The restaurant exudes island-style charm with its brightly painted walls and plenty of natural light. The menu features a range of mouthwatering options, but the must-try pizza is the Local Pie, which showcases the flavors of Maui with its locally sourced ingredients.

Transitioning to the next section, we shift our focus to another popular pizzeria in Maui: Prison St Pizza.

Prison St Pizza

Prison St Pizza, a family-owned pizzeria since 2014, offers generous toppings and flavors that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover.

The lively and rustic vibe of the restaurant adds to the overall dining experience, and the huge portions of delicious pizza are perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Paired with local island beers, the signature pizza at Prison St Pizza is a must-try for those seeking a memorable pizza adventure.

Generous Toppings and Flavors

We can't wait to try the signature pizza at Prison St Pizza, known for its generous toppings and flavorful combinations. This popular pizzeria in Maui offers a wide variety of options that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover.

Here are some reasons why Prison St Pizza is considered one of the best pizza places in Maui:

• Fresh ingredients sourced locally to ensure quality and taste.
• Attention to detail in every pizza, from the handmade dough to the perfectly melted cheese.
• Diverse menu with options for vegetarians, meat lovers, and everyone in between.
• Friendly and knowledgeable staff who prioritize customer satisfaction.

Prison St Pizza has been family-owned since 2014, adding a personal touch to every pizza they serve. Their dedication to providing delicious and satisfying meals has earned them a loyal following.

Family-Owned Since 2014

We've heard great things about Prison St Pizza and their commitment to being family-owned since 2014. This pizzeria has gained a reputation for its lively and rustic vibe, offering huge portions of delicious pizza that are perfect for sharing with the family.

Prison St Pizza also takes pride in supporting local businesses by pairing their pizzas with local island beers. They've a signature pizza that's packed with generous toppings, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor.

For those who value safety, this family-owned establishment provides a welcoming and cozy atmosphere where you can enjoy your meal without any worries.

Speaking of family-owned pizzerias, another great option to consider is Fabiani's Bakery and Pizza, which we'll discuss in the next section.

Fabianis Bakery and Pizza

I've heard great things about Fabianis Bakery and Pizza, and I can't wait to try their handmade Italian-American dishes and baked goods. Located in Maui, HI, this family-owned and operated establishment has been serving up delicious food since 2012. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, complete with rustic wood accents, Fabianis Bakery and Pizza creates the perfect ambiance for a cozy and enjoyable dining experience.

Here are some reasons why Fabianis Bakery and Pizza stands out:

• Authentic Italian-American Cuisine: Fabianis Bakery and Pizza prides itself on serving handmade dishes that stay true to their Italian-American roots. From classic pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, their menu offers a wide range of options that will satisfy any craving.
• Lively Local Atmosphere: As a popular spot among locals, Fabianis Bakery and Pizza is always buzzing with lively chatter and friendly faces. You'll feel right at home as you enjoy your meal in the company of fellow food enthusiasts.
• Freshly Baked Goods: In addition to their savory dishes, Fabianis Bakery and Pizza also offers a selection of freshly baked goods. From bread to pastries, their bakery items are made with love and care, ensuring a delightful treat for your taste buds.
• Must-Try Pizza: One dish that stands out is the Maui Sunrise pizza. Topped with pineapple and bacon, this unique combination of flavors perfectly captures the essence of Hawaiian cuisine.

With its commitment to quality and a welcoming atmosphere, Fabianis Bakery and Pizza is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking delicious Italian-American cuisine in Maui, HI.

Sale Pepe

Let's check out Sale Pepe, a family-owned Italian bistro known for its authentic and classic Italian dishes. Located in Maui, Sale Pepe is a popular destination for locals and tourists alike in search of the best pizza in Maui. With a chic and modern interior design, the restaurant offers a bright and cheerful ambiance with a rustic Mediterranean feel.

At Sale Pepe, you can expect to find a wide variety of pizza options made with fresh ingredients and traditional Italian flavors. One of their standout pizzas is the classic Margherita, topped with fresh San Marzano tomatoes and melted mozzarella cheese. The combination of the tangy tomatoes and creamy cheese creates a perfect harmony of flavors.

When it comes to safety, Sale Pepe ensures a clean and hygienic environment for its customers. The staff follows strict sanitation protocols, and the restaurant adheres to all health and safety guidelines. With their commitment to providing a safe dining experience, you can enjoy your meal at Sale Pepe with peace of mind.

If you're in Maui and craving authentic Italian pizza, Sale Pepe is a must-visit. Their dedication to quality ingredients and traditional recipes make them a top contender for the best pizza in Maui. So come on over and indulge in a slice of Italy right here on the beautiful island of Maui.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Any of These Pizza Places Vegetarian-Friendly?

Some of the pizza places mentioned in the list are vegetarian-friendly.

We recommend checking out the Mediterranean Pizza Place, which offers Mediterranean-style pizzas with fresh and flavorful ingredients. They've a cozy and rustic atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a casual family dinner.

Another option is Dollies Pub & Cafe, where you can find a signature dish of Hawaiian-style pizza topped with pineapple and melted cheese.

Both places offer tasty options for vegetarian pizza lovers.

Do Any of These Pizza Places Offer Gluten-Free Pizza Options?

Yes, some of these pizza places in Maui offer gluten-free pizza options.

While the specific details for each pizza joint aren't provided, it's common for pizzerias to cater to dietary restrictions and offer gluten-free crusts.

So, if you're looking for gluten-free pizza options in Maui, it's worth checking out the various pizza places mentioned in the previous discussion.

They may have gluten-free options available to accommodate your dietary needs.

Are There Any Vegan Pizza Options Available at These Pizzerias?

There are several pizzerias in Maui that offer vegan pizza options. Each of these places has their own unique take on vegan pizza, with delicious flavors and fresh ingredients.

Whether you're looking for a Mediterranean-inspired pizza or a classic Hawaiian-style pie, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings.

These pizzerias understand the importance of catering to different dietary needs and provide options that aren't only vegan but also full of flavor and satisfaction.

Do Any of These Pizza Places Offer Delivery Services?

Yes, some of the pizza places mentioned in the list offer delivery services.

While the specific details of each establishment's delivery options aren't provided, it's common for pizzerias to offer delivery as a convenient option for their customers.

It's always best to contact the individual pizza places directly to inquire about their delivery services, as availability may vary.

Are There Any Happy Hour Specials or Discounts Available at These Pizza Places?

There are several pizza places in Maui, HI that offer happy hour specials or discounts. Some of them include:

• Dollies Pub & Cafe
• Johnnys Heist
• Mediterranean Pizza Place
• Pizza Joint 4

These places provide a variety of options and atmospheres, from lively sports bars to cozy and rustic settings.

It's always a good idea to call ahead or check their websites for specific happy hour times and deals.

Conclusion

In conclusion, our journey through the best pizza spots in Maui, HI has left us feeling like we've discovered a hidden culinary gem.

From the rustic charm of Flatbread Company to the wild flavors at Pizza Madness Maui, each pizzeria offers a unique and mouthwatering experience.

So go ahead and indulge in a slice of paradise, because when it comes to pizza in Maui, the options are truly anachronistic and delicious.