Dreaming of the dazzling lights and dynamic energy of New York City?  As you prepare for your epic New York adventure, ensuring a secure and peaceful stay is undoubtedly a top priority. That’s where I come in! In this comprehensive blog post, I’m going to guide you through the safest places to stay in New York!

I totally understand that finding the perfect accommodation is not just about comfort and convenience – it’s also about peace of mind. New York is one of my favorite cities, but like any big city, it’s essential to be smart about your safety. 

From charming neighborhoods with a strong sense of community to modern hotels equipped with top-notch security features, I’m here to provide you with a range of options that prioritize your safety and well-being.

Whether you’re a solo traveler like me, a family with little explorers, or a couple seeking a romantic getaway, my carefully curated recommendations will ensure that your New York experience is not only unforgettable but also worry-free. 

So, let’s dive into the details of the safest places to stay in New York and discover the perfect sanctuary for your stay in the Big Apple.

Safest Places To Stay in New York 

Here are the safest places to stay in New York. From infamous inner-city stays to more suburban neighborhoods that will unlock a whole different experience in NYC. 

Midtown Manhattan 

Midtown Manhattan, the vibrant heart of the Big Apple, combines accessibility, entertainment, and a strong sense of safety. With well-lit streets, constant activity, and a visible police presence, the neighborhood fosters a secure environment for all, around the clock.

Midtown boasts iconic landmarks. From the dazzling lights of Times Square to the breathtaking Empire State Building, you can explore renowned attractions while feeling at ease. Midtown Manhattan is undoubtedly one of the best places to stay in New York for first-timers wanting to hit all the major attractions. 

The Theater District offers Broadway’s finest. Immersing yourself in live performances and exploring cultural havens like the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) is the perfect taste of New York art and Broadway scene.

Escape to Central Park, just steps away from Midtown’s hustle. The park’s gorgeous landscapes offer a secure retreat for relaxation and recreation.

Navigating the city is a breeze, thanks to transport hubs like Penn Station and Grand Central Terminal. This ensures safe exploration of neighboring areas with Midtown as your secure home base.

Being such a central and in-demand area, it’s important to note, that staying in Midtown Manhattan can cost a pretty penny.

Safest Places to Stay in Midtown Manhattan

These central accommodations are excellent choices for first timers in New York looking to hit all the sites.

CIVILIAN Hotel

8.5/10 2181 reviews

Staying at the CIVILIAN Hotel in Midtown Manhattan offers more than just incredible value accommodation – it provides a secure and inviting haven for your New York City experience. A double room starts at $170 per night depending on the season you visit.

Situated in the heart of the city, the hotel combines modern comfort with a commitment to safety, ensuring that your stay is both enjoyable and worry-free.

With its prime location, the CIVILIAN Hotel places you within easy reach of iconic attractions and convenient transportation options. Its well-lit surroundings and close proximity to key attractions including Broadway Theatre and Rockefeller Centre, contribute to a secure atmosphere.

From the moment you step through its doors, you’ll find a welcoming and attentive staff who are there 24/7 and are dedicated to ensuring your well-being. The establishment’s security measures, such as key card access and round-the-clock surveillance, further enhance the sense of safety during your stay.

CIVILIAN Hotel’s thoughtfully designed rooms provide a relaxing retreat. Plus the views from the hotel are pretty incredible!

Click here to book your stay at CIVILIAN Hotel

Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square

8.6/10 8822 reviews

A stay at the Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square ensures not only comfortable and stylish accommodation but also a safe and convenient experience in the heart of New York City. A Deluxe King room starts at just over $200 a night.

Situated in the bustling Times Square area, this hotel goes above and beyond to prioritize your well-being while offering a prime location for your NYC adventures.

The Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square’s commitment to safety starts with its welcoming and attentive 24/7 staff who are dedicated to ensuring a secure environment throughout your stay. With modern security measures in place, such as key card access and surveillance systems, you can rest assured that your safety is a top priority.

The hotel’s central location means you’re steps away from the vibrant energy of Times Square and within easy reach of various attractions and transportation options. Whether you’re exploring the city during the day or night, the well-lit surroundings and active atmosphere contribute to a secure environment.

Inside the hotel, you’ll find thoughtfully designed rooms that offer a comfortable stay.

In addition to its comfortable accommodations, the hotel features amenities that cater to your convenience and enjoyment. From on-site dining options, a bar to fitness facilities, you’ll have everything you need within a secure and welcoming environment.

And free breakfast is included!

Book your stay at Riu Plaza Manhattan Times Square

Upper West Side (Where I stayed!)

The Upper West Side stands out as one of the safest and most appealing places to stay in New York City. As someone who has chosen to stay in the Upper West Side, I can safely say it won’t disappoint!

Nestled between Central Park and the Hudson River, this charming neighborhood offers a serene escape from the bustling city while providing easy access to all Manhattan offers.

Known for its upscale residential vibe, the Upper West Side exudes a sense of security that’s perfect for both travelers and locals. The streets are well-lit, and the neighborhood benefits from a strong police presence, contributing to its reputation as a safe haven.

With a mix of historic brownstones, tree-lined streets, and cultural landmarks, the Upper West Side is something special. 

Let’s talk about food, dining options are diverse and plentiful, ranging from classic delis to upscale eateries. Local shops and markets add to the neighborhood’s cozy feel, giving you a taste of the authentic New York experience. Plus you can easily walk to a nearby supermarket for a cheap meal in your hotel!

If you’re looking to explore other parts of the city, convenient subway lines make it a breeze to get around. 

Whether you’re strolling through Central Park, catching a show at a Broadway theater, or simply enjoying the relaxed vibe of the Upper West Side, your stay here promises safety, comfort, and an unforgettable New York experience.

Best Place to Stay on the Upper West Side

This is where I stayed with my family on a trip to New York!

Hotel Beacon (Where I stayed!)

8.7/10 1773 reviews

Opting for Hotel Beacon offers more than just a place to lay your head – it provides a secure and welcoming haven in the heart of New York City’s Upper West Side. King Studio rooms start at around $252 a night.

Hotel Beacon’s commitment to safety starts with its attentive 24/7 staff, dedicated to creating a secure and inviting environment for all guests. With a doorman, key card access and modern security measures in place, you can explore the city with confidence, knowing that your well-being is a top priority.

The hotel’s location on the Upper West Side is fantastic. It’s seriously such a gorgeous area. You’ll have the chance to experience the city’s vibrant energy while enjoying a peaceful retreat. There are supermarkets, cafes, diners, and restaurants all within walking distance.

Inside the hotel, you’ll find comfortable and thoughtfully designed rooms. There is also a cozy lobby where you can hang out with other travelers.

With its array of amenities, from fully equipped kitchens to spacious suites, Hotel Beacon offers more than just a place to sleep. It provides a home away from home, where you can immerse yourself in the local neighborhood and enjoy the city’s offerings with peace of mind.

Click here to book your stay at Hotel Beacon

Upper East Side

The Upper East Side stands as a shining example of a safe and upscale haven within New York City. Renowned for its elegance and sophistication, this neighborhood is a top choice for travelers seeking comfort, security, and a touch of luxury.

Safety is paramount in the Upper East Side. The streets are well-maintained, well-lit, and consistently patrolled, creating an environment where people stroll with peace of mind, even after dark.

The neighborhood’s refined ambiance is complemented by its proximity to world-class cultural institutions. The iconic Museum Mile along Fifth Avenue offers an array of museums, including The Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, making it the perfect sport for art and history enthusiasts to stay.

The Upper East Side’s culinary scene mirrors its upscale reputation, featuring a variety of world-class restaurants that cater to discerning palates. Whether you’re craving classic New York deli fare or indulging in gourmet cuisine, the options are as safe as they are delicious.

Staying on the Upper East Side means you’re within reach of Central Park ideal for walks or picnics to escape the chaotic city. Convenient access to the subway ensures you can easily explore other parts of the city whenever you want.

Safest Place to Stay on the Upper East Side

This is my recommended stay on the Upper East Side which offers exceptional value.

voco The Franklin New York, an IHG Hotel

Selecting voco The Franklin New York, an IHG Hotel, for your stay ensures not only a luxurious accommodation but also a safe and serene escape in the vibrant NYC. A double room starts at $246 per night.

Situated in the heart of Manhattan’s Upper East Side, this hotel offers a blend of elegance, comfort, and of course, security.

At Voco The Franklin New York, your safety is paramount. The hotel’s attentive staff and modern security measures create a secure environment, allowing you to explore the city and its attractions with peace of mind. Key card access and surveillance systems contribute to the overall sense of safety throughout your stay.

Located in the refined Upper East Side neighborhood, the hotel is in a prime location.

The hotel’s central location means you’re just moments away from iconic attractions, world-class museums, and a range of places to eat out.

Inside the hotel, you’ll find an elegantly designed room that provides everything you need including toiletries, airconditioning, a safety deposit box, and even bath robes. And need I mention they have 24-hour espresso and cappuccino service so you can fuel up at any time of day!

Grab a cup of cappuccino and enjoy the stunning views from the hotel.

Check the availability of Voco The Franklin New York

Williamsburg 

Williamsburg is a dynamic neighborhood in Brooklyn and has emerged as a trendy yet safe place to stay in New York City. With its creative energy, artistic flair, and a sense of community, it offers a wonderfully diverse experience that attracts travelers from all walks of life.

Safety in Williamsburg is apparent through well-lit streets, a visible police presence, and a strong sense of neighborhood camaraderie. This means locals and travelers can explore with confidence, whether it’s day or night.

What sets Williamsburg apart from other places to stay in New York is its thriving arts and cultural scene. From street art to galleries, the neighborhood is a haven for creativity. Whilst you’re there you’ve got to visit the Williamsburg Waterfront for a tranquil escape with stunning Manhattan skyline views.

Foodies will also be impressed with trendy cafes, innovative eateries, and traditional establishments.

Williamsburg’s unique character extends to its boutique shops, vintage stores, and independent businesses. Although it’s no Soho, exploring these spots reveals the neighborhood’s authentic spirit and adds to the overall sense of safety.

Access to Manhattan is a breeze with multiple transport options, including the subway and ferry. This makes it convenient to explore other parts of the city while having a secure base in Williamsburg.

Safest Places To Stay in Williamsburg

These are my recommendations on the safest places to stay in New York, Williamsburg.

Wythe Hotel

8.9/10 260 reviews

Located along the Brooklyn waterfront, the Wythe Hotel, housed within a carefully converted 100-year-old factory, is a unique gem that seamlessly blends industrial character with modern comfort. Preserving its historic charm, the hotel showcases exposed brick walls that echo its heritage.

A bunk bedroom starts at $218 per night.

Safety and comfort go hand in hand at Wythe Hotel. With 69 rooms boasting 13-foot-high original timber ceilings, windows, and heated concrete floors, you’ll find a secure and inviting environment for your stay.

Some rooms offer breathtaking views of the New York City skyline, while others provide a glimpse into the vibrant Brooklyn and Williamsburg neighborhoods.

Treat yourself to a meal at Le Crocodile, the hotel’s ground floor restaurant, where locally sourced ingredients are transformed into French-inspired breakfasts, lunches, and dinners.

Bar Blondeau, situated on the 6th floor, offers a cozy setting for enjoying small plates and refreshments. For those seeking a more intimate dining experience, a private dining room is available. Took about a memorable experience.

Conveniently, the North Williamsburg stop for the East River Ferry is just a short distance of 644 meters from the property, providing secure and easy access to explore the city.

Couples in particular appreciate the exceptional location, rating it 9.4 for a romantic getaway.

Book your stay at Whyteh Hotel

Penny Williamsburg

8.9/10 757 reviews

Penny Williamsburg, located in Brooklyn is a 4-star hotel that boasts a restaurant, bar, and terrace, all enveloped in a secure and relaxed atmosphere. A queen room starts at $176 per night which is excellent value for New York.

With complimentary bikes, room service, and free WiFi, your experience is elevated to a new level of convenience.

Safety is a priority at Penny Williamsburg. There is a 24/7 help desk, 24-hour security, CCTV, key card access, and safety deposit boxes are provided in each room.

Each unit is thoughtfully equipped with modern essentials such as a fridge, microwave, coffee machine, hairdryer, and desk. Your privacy and comfort are paramount, and each room features a private bathroom with slippers and bathrobes for your relaxation.

The reception team speaks various languages, including Arabic, Bulgarian, Greek, and English, providing a welcoming environment for international travelers.

Click here to book your stay at Penny Williamsburg

Tribeca

Tribeca, short for “Triangle Below Canal Street,” has a chic yet inviting atmosphere that prioritizes safety. Well-maintained streets and a sense of community contribute to an environment where you can explore without worries.

Tribeca’s historic industrial buildings have been transformed into upscale lofts, creating a unique blend of old and new. The neighborhood’s commitment to safety is reflected in its family-friendly ambiance.

An array of upscale dining establishments and charming cafes await in Tribeca. The culinary scene embodies sophistication and ensures that you can savor delicious meals in a secure and stylish setting.

The green spaces along the Hudson River, such as Hudson River Park, offer a wonderful retreat for relaxation and outdoor activities. 

Safest Accommodation in Tribeca

This is my recommended stay in Tribeca for a safe and memorable stay.

Sheraton Tribeca New York Hotel

7.6/10 2772 reviews

Located in the Tribeca neighborhood, this 4-star gem in the heart of New York City is a haven of modern comfort. Just across the street from the chic SoHo shopping district, the Sheraton Tribeca New York Hotel offers a range of amenities, including contemporary guest rooms, a 24-hour gym, and a restaurant.

Every guest room at the Sheraton Tribeca features a 32-inch flat-screen TV, free Wi-Fi, and a convenient work desk. For a touch of urban elegance, some rooms offer mesmerizing views of Midtown and the Hudson River.

Safety is paramount at the Sheraton. There is a 24/7 help desk, security, CCTV, and each room is equipped with safety deposit boxes.

Indulge your taste buds in the hotel’s full-service restaurant, where American cuisine is served for breakfast and dinner.

Whether you prefer to dine in or grab a coffee to go, the hotel caters to you. Relax at the the Lobby Lounge with a wine or cocktail, while the on-site Starbucks offers a delightful caffeine fix.

With the Canal Street Subway Station conveniently less than 1 block away, navigating the city is a breeze. The hotel’s location is further enriched by its proximity to attractions like the Holland Tunnel and Greenwich Village.

Click here to book the Sheraton Tribeca New York Hotel

Staten Island

Staten Island, often referred to as the “Forgotten Borough,” is a hidden gem within New York City that offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and city accessibility. While not as bustling as some other parts of the city, Staten Island boasts a distinct charm that makes it a safe and delightful place to explore.

Safety is a defining characteristic of Staten Island. With its close-knit communities and low crime rates, Staten Island is undoubtedly one of the safest places to stay in New York. 

One of Staten Island’s crown jewels is its parks. The Staten Island Greenbelt, Clove Lakes Park, and Fort Wadsworth are just a few examples of the borough’s green offerings, where you can bask in nature’s beauty and escape the city’s hustle and bustle.

The Staten Island Ferry offers not only stunning views of the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline but also a reliable and secure means of transport to and from the borough. This makes it easy to explore other parts of the city while having a comfortable and safe base in Staten Island.

Staten Island’s cultural scene is alive with local museums, historic sites, and charming neighborhoods like St. George and Historic Richmond Town. The blend of safety and cultural richness creates an experience that showcases the borough’s unique identity.

Safest Hotels in Staten Island

This is my recommended stay in Staten Island for a safe stay that won’t break the bank.

Hampton Inn & Suites Staten Island

8.3/10 963 reviews

Conveniently located on Staten Island, this hotel prioritizes safety while offering a range of amenities that ensure a comfortable stay.

A fully-equipped gym awaits if you want a little more than walking around the city and Central Park for exercise. A king studio starts at $170 per night.

At Hampton Inn & Suites Staten Island, your comfort is paramount. Each room comes complete with free Wi-Fi, coffee facilities and the added convenience of pay-per-view movies. The suites elevate your experience, offering spacious seating areas along with a microwave and a refrigerator.

For secure and convenient transportation, Staten Island Hampton Inn offers a local area shuttle to destinations including the Staten Island Ferry, Newark, and Cape Liberty Cruise Port. Plus, a 24-hour convenience store ensures that your essentials are easily accessible.

Explore nearby attractions such as the Staten Island Zoo, located just 4.1 miles away. Situated off the West Shore Expressway, Hampton Inn & Suites is a mere 12 miles from the Statue of Liberty. For those who enjoy keeping fit on their travels, a 2-mile jogging path is within easy reach.

Click here to book your stay at Hampton Inn & Suites Staten Island

Chelsea

Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, Chelsea is a neighborhood that seamlessly blends creativity, modern living, and a strong sense of safety. This vibrant area has become one of the most sought-after safest places to stay in New York City, Let’s unpack why.

Safety is paramount in Chelsea. The streets are well-maintained and illuminated, and you’ll police line the street to protect the area. You can confidently explore the diverse offerings, whether you’re discovering galleries, dining out, or strolling along the iconic High Line.

Chelsea’s art scene is second to none. The neighborhood houses an array of galleries, from contemporary showcases to renowned institutions like the Whitney Museum of American Art. This cultural richness provides a safe and engaging backdrop for art enthusiasts.

Foodies will find themselves in a culinary paradise. Chelsea boasts an eclectic mix of eateries, ranging from cozy cafes to upscale restaurants, all reflecting the neighborhood’s diversity and commitment to safety.

The Chelsea Market is a must-visit, offering a blend of gourmet food vendors, artisanal shops, and local vendors. It’s a space where you can shop, eat, and mingle in a secure and friendly environment.

With its proximity to attractions like the Hudson River Park, Chelsea offers a balance between city fun and outdoor leisure. Access to public transport is a breeze ensuring you can effortlessly venture into other parts of the city while having a safe haven to return to.

Where to stay in Chelsea

Got your heart set on staying in Chelsea? This is my favorite hotel that is very safe and offers great value for your dollar.

The Moore

8.5/10 1168 reviews

Discover The Moore, an 81-room boutique hotel in the heart of Chelsea, New York that offers a safe retreat. A queen room starts at $236 per night.

With a rooftop oasis, fitness center, and complimentary WiFi, your experience is elevated to a new level of comfort. The hotel is ideally situated just 1 km from Madison Square Park/Flatiron and a mere 800 meters from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.

Each room features a flat-screen TV with cable channels and a private bathroom with a bath or shower, along with bathrobes, complimentary toiletries, and a hairdryer. And daily housekeeping will ensure your room stays neat and tidy.

A 24-hour front desk stands ready to offer concierge services, ensuring that your needs are met around the clock. An on-site bar provides a convenient spot to unwind and enjoy your surroundings.

The allure of The Moore is further enhanced by its proximity to attractions such as Highline Park, a mere 900 meters away, and the iconic Macy’s, located just 1.1 km from the property.

Couples, in particular, rave about the location, awarding it a high rating of 9.3 for romantic getaways.

Book your stay at The Moore in Chelsea

Brooklyn Heights

Brooklyn Heights is a historic gem along the East River, offering a charming blend of old-world elegance and modern comfort. 

Renowned for its tree-lined streets, stunning architecture, and family-friendly atmosphere, this neighborhood provides a safe place to stay in New York for a quintessential Brooklyn experience. It is one of the top places to live in New York.

Historic brownstones and architectural wonders give Brooklyn Heights its distinctive character. Walking along the Promenade rewards you with breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline, the Statue of Liberty, and the Brooklyn Bridge – all within a secure and peaceful environment.

Dining options range from cozy cafes to upscale eateries, reflecting the neighborhood’s commitment to both safety and culinary excellence. Plus there’s somewhere to eat for every budget. Whether you’re seeking classic comfort food or international flavors, Brooklyn Heights caters to a diverse range of palates.

Proximity to attractions like DUMBO’s artsy vibe, Brooklyn Bridge Park’s green spaces, and easy access to Manhattan make Brooklyn Heights an ideal base for exploring the city.

The neighborhood’s strong sense of community is reflected in local markets, boutique shops, and family-friendly parks. Brooklyn Heights offers a balance between historic charm and contemporary convenience, making it one of the safest places to stay in New York.

Safest Place to Stay in Brooklyn Heights

Lastly, we have a stunning hotel located in the gorgeous neighborhood, of Brooklyn Heights.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

8.3/10 659 reviews

Indulge in an unparalleled experience with the luxurious service at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge. Now when I say luxury, I mean it, a double room starts at $518 per night.

This waterfront haven, spanning 10 stories, offers a distinctive blend of opulence and nature. Situated a mere 600 meters from Brooklyn Bridge and 300 meters from the East River, the hotel’s prime location is hard to beat!

As part of the premium experience, guests have the privilege of accessing an Audi E-Tron vehicle for complimentary rides within a 3-mile radius. Make sure to make the most of this safe and luxurious way to get around the city.

The property boasts communal spaces designed for both productivity and relaxation. The 24-hour Fieldhouse fitness center ensures you stay fit, while the 50-person screening room will keep you entertained. For a quick bite, the grab-and-go café presents a menu crafted from locally sourced ingredients.

Spa and wellness options, along with complimentary WiFi, complete the comprehensive experience.

But you simply can’t beat the views of New York from the rooftop. It is worth the pretty penny.