Get Even More Visitors To Your Blog, Upgrade To A Business Listing >>

Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island


Best Places to Eat on Anna Maria Island

The Beaches of Anna Maria
Seafood on Anna Maria Island
Stone Crab Best on Anna Maria

Anna Maria Island is a charming barrier island located on the Gulf of Mexico in Manatee County, Florida. Anna Maria Island is approximately seven miles long and is situated south of Tampa Bay and north of Sarasota.

It is easily accessible by car and is connected to the mainland by three bridges. The island is renowned for its pristine white-sand beaches, including Anna Maria City Beach, Holmes Beach, and Bradenton Beach.

On these communities are the best restaurants on Anna Maria Island Florida. They range from quaint colorful café’s to sprawling beachfront places to dip your toes in the sand while sipping on a margarita.

About Anna Maria Island Florida

The island embraces a quaint and Old Florida atmosphere, with low-rise buildings, boutique shops, and locally-owned restaurants. There is a strong emphasis on preserving the island’s natural beauty and charm.

In addition to beach activities, Anna Maria Island offers opportunities for boating, fishing, kayaking, and paddleboarding. The island is also known for its picturesque piers, such as the City Pier in Anna Maria and the Historic Bridge Street Pier in Bradenton Beach.

Our goal in this post is to identify the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island and offer some details for choosing your dining destination on the island.

Our favorite restaurants in Anna Maria Island Florida are marked with an asterisk *.

The Ugly Grouper Restaurant Anna Maria.
Beach Bistro Upscale Dining

The Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

The “Notes” below each restaurant are our impressions as we visited the area or dined there. The list is random order not denoting any preference.
  • The Ugly Grouper

The Ugly Grouper is known for its casual, laid-back atmosphere and is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The restaurant offers a diverse menu with a focus on seafood, including grouper – Florida’s local fish. In addition to seafood, you can find a variety of dishes, from burgers and sandwiches to salads and appetizers.

One of the highlights of The Ugly Grouper is its waterfront location, providing patrons with beautiful views of the water while enjoying their meals. The outdoor seating area is often favored, allowing guests to soak in the Florida sunshine and enjoy a relaxed dining experience. 

Live music and entertainment are also common at The Ugly Grouper, contributing to the vibrant and lively ambiance. Locals say this is one of the best places to eat on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Casual, beachfront, fun

  • Beach Bistro*

Beach Bistro is known for its fine dining experience, exquisite cuisine, and stunning Gulf-front location. The restaurant is celebrated for its commitment to high-quality ingredients, creative culinary techniques, and an extensive wine list. It offers a menu that showcases a blend of contemporary American and Gulf Coast cuisine, often featuring fresh seafood.

One of the unique aspects of Beach Bistro is its beachfront setting, allowing diners to enjoy picturesque views of the Gulf of Mexico. The elegant yet relaxed atmosphere, combined with attentive service, makes it a popular choice for special occasions or those looking for a memorable dining experience.

Due to its popularity and reputation, reservations are often recommended, especially during peak seasons. If you ask Google for “seafood restaurants near me”, Beach Bistro is one of the top seafood restaurants in Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Upscale, romantic, waterfront

  • Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus

Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus is known for offering authentic German cuisine in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant’s menu typically includes a variety of traditional German dishes, with a focus on specialties like schnitzels, bratwurst, sauerbraten, and other classic German fare. The ambiance often reflects a warm and charming European feel.

One of the highlights of the restaurant is its commitment to providing an authentic dining experience, including using quality ingredients and preparing dishes with attention to traditional German recipes. 

The menu may also feature a selection of German beers and wines to complement the culinary offerings. The Schnitzelhaus is one of several ethnic restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Authentic, Bar, evening dining

  • Ginny’s and Jane E’s Cafe and Coastal Store

Ginny’s and Jane E’s is a popular cafe and boutique located on Anna Maria Island in Florida.

Ginny’s and Jane E’s is known for its eclectic and charming atmosphere, offering a unique blend of cafe dining and boutique shopping. The cafe serves breakfast and lunch, and its menu often features a variety of delicious items, including fresh baked goods, sandwiches, salads, and coffee. Visitors often appreciate the cozy and beachy ambiance, making it a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike.

One distinctive feature of Ginny’s and Jane E’s is its combination of a cafe and boutique. While enjoying a meal or a cup of coffee, patrons can also explore the boutique area, which typically offers a curated selection of gifts, home decor, and beach-inspired items. One of the popular breakfast restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Beachy feel, lunch & breakfast

The Sandbar Restaurant on Anna Maria
Hurricane Hanks Anna Maria
  • Hurricane Hanks

Hurricane Hanks is a casual, welcoming pub on Anna Maria Island that has been serving up delicious food and drinks since 2000. A favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike, thanks to its friendly atmosphere, fresh ingredients, and wide selection of menu items.

Hurricane Hanks’ menu features a variety of pub favorites, including beer-battered fish, sandwiches, burgers, and salads. They also have a great selection of appetizers, sides, and desserts.

Hurricane Hanks has a full bar with a wide variety of beers, wines, and cocktails. They also have a great selection of non-alcoholic beverages.

Hurricane Hanks is a casual and relaxed place to enjoy a meal or drinks with friends. The restaurant has a spacious indoor dining area, as well as a large outdoor patio.

Hank’s is known for their great sandwiches including a great burger and superb grouper sandwich. Salads are excellent also.

Hurricane Hanks is open for lunch and dinner seven days a week. They also have a great brunch menu that is available on Sundays.

Notes: Good on Holmes Beach, full bar

  • Two Scoops*

Two Scoops Ice Cream is a popular ice cream shop located on Anna Maria Island in Florida. 

Two Scoops is known for serving a wide variety of delicious ice cream flavors in a casual and welcoming atmosphere. 

The shop typically offers a range of classic and unique flavors, and customers can enjoy their ice cream in cones, cups, or as part of sundaes and other treats. The vibrant and colorful decor creates a cheerful setting for customers of all ages.

Many visitors appreciate the friendly service and the opportunity to indulge in a sweet treat while exploring Anna Maria Island. Two Scoops is often regarded as a family-friendly destination, making it a popular stop for both locals and tourists enjoying the island’s laid-back atmosphere. Two Scoops is one of the popular restaurants on Anna Maria island.

Notes: Fun place for Ice Cream

  • Isola Bella Italian Eatery*

In the heart of Anna Maria Island, Isola Bella Italian Eatery transports you to the rustic charm of Sicily with its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, welcoming atmosphere. 

Founded in 2012, this family-owned restaurant has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, earning rave reviews for its delectable dishes, friendly service, and genuine Italian hospitality.

Step inside Isola Bella and you’re immediately greeted by the tantalizing aroma of wood-fired pizza, simmering sauces, and fresh herbs. The restaurant’s ambiance is both rustic and inviting, with exposed brick walls, cozy booths, and soft lighting. 

The walls are adorned with photographs of Sicily, adding a touch of authenticity to the dining experience.

The menu at Isola Bella features a wide selection of classic Italian dishes, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Start your meal with a selection of antipasti, such as bruschetta, calamari fritti, or caprese salad. For your main course, indulge in pasta dishes like spaghetti carbonara, lasagna, or penne arrabbiata. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, try the chicken parmigiana or the veal marsala. For dessert, don’t miss the tiramisu or the cannoli, both made fresh daily.

Isola Bella Italian Eatery is open for dinner Tuesday through Sunday from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM. They offer indoor and outdoor seating, and reservations are recommended, especially during peak season. One of the most popular Italian restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Upscale Italian, evening dining, authentic

  • The Sandbar Seafood & Spirits

In the vibrant coastal scenery of Anna Maria Island, The Sandbar Seafood & Spirits beckons with its panoramic Gulf views. Since its inception in 2000, this beloved waterfront restaurant has garnered a reputation as a haven for seafood enthusiasts and casual diners alike, consistently exceeding expectations with its fresh, innovative cuisine and warm, welcoming atmosphere.

The restaurant’s interior exudes a relaxed beachside vibe with its exposed brick walls, wooden accents, and expansive windows that frame breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico.

The Sandbar’s showcases the finest local seafood alongside innovative culinary creations that tantalize the taste buds. Their signature Aguachile Ceviche, featuring cobia, avocado, and pickled onions, is a refreshing and zesty starter, while the Shishito Peppers, drizzled with sesame ginger sauce, offer a delightful kick.

For a taste of the sea, indulge in the Grilled Grouper Sandwich, a delightful combination of flaky grouper, lump crabmeat, and remoulade, or savor the Stuffed Shrimp, a culinary masterpiece filled with crabmeat stuffing, Bahamian rice, and farm vegetables. The Sandbar is one of the busy restaurants on Anna Maria Island beach.

Whether you seek a romantic sunset dinner, a lively family gathering, or a casual lunch with friends, The Sandbar Seafood & Spirits seamlessly caters to every occasion. With its panoramic ocean views, fresh and innovative cuisine, and warm, welcoming atmosphere, The Sandbar is a true gem of Anna Maria Island, where culinary artistry meets coastal charm.

Notes: Upscale beach bar, great views

Bridge Tender Inn Tiki Bar
Rod and Reel Pier a locals hideout!
  • Bridge Tender Inn*

The Bridge Tender Inn is a waterfront restaurant located on Anna Maria Island in Florida.

The Bridge Tender Inn is well-known for its picturesque location along the Intracoastal Waterway. The restaurant offers a casual and laid-back atmosphere, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The waterfront setting allows patrons to enjoy beautiful views while dining on the outdoor deck or inside the restaurant.

The menu at the Bridge Tender Inn typically includes a variety of seafood dishes, as well as options for land lovers. Fresh seafood, including fish and shrimp, is often featured, and the restaurant is known for its casual fare and relaxed ambiance. 

Additionally, the establishment may offer a selection of cocktails, beers, and wines to complement the dining experience. If you want to know where do the locals eat on Anna Maria Island, this is it!

Notes: Fun with music daily, basic pub fare, Tiki Bar, sports bar vibe

  • Coquina Beach Café
Coquina Beach Cafe

Right on the sands of Coquina Beach, Coquina Beach Café offers a delightful blend of casual dining, stunning ocean views, and a touch of island charm. This beloved beachfront gem has been a favorite among locals and visitors alike since its inception in 1952, consistently delivering a taste of the tropics with its fresh, flavorful cuisine and welcoming atmosphere.

The café’s beachfront location provides views of the Gulf of Mexico. Whether you choose to dine alfresco on the expansive patio or bask in the cool comfort of the indoor seating area, the mesmerizing ocean vista adds a touch of magic to your dining experience.

Coquina Beach Café’s menu is a testament to the flavors of Anna Maria Island, showcasing a delightful array of casual fare that caters to every palate. Start your day with a hearty breakfast, indulging in fluffy omelets, golden pancakes, or crispy French toast.

 For lunch, savor the fresh flavors of the sea with their delectable fish tacos, juicy burgers, or refreshing salads. And as the sun begins its descent, indulge in a satisfying dinner, choosing from a selection of grilled seafood platters, savory sandwiches, or their signature Coquina Fries, a delectable medley of fries, cheese, and bacon.

Another one of the very popular beach restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Beach views are great, casual, pub fare

  • The Feast
Food at The Feast

The Feast Restaurant has always been a haven for discerning diners seeking a culinary escape. Since its inception in 2009, this beloved establishment has garnered a reputation as a gem of Anna Maria Island and one of the popular Holmes Beach restaurants.

The restaurant’s interior exudes a relaxed beachside vibe with its warm wooden accents, exposed brick walls, and soft lighting. The ambiance is further enhanced by the gentle hum of conversation and the tantalizing aromas wafting from the kitchen, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

Their signature Pasta Primavera, featuring a medley of fresh vegetables, herbs, and a delicate white wine sauce, exemplifies their commitment to freshness and flavor. For a taste of the sea, indulge in the Grilled Grouper with Lemon Caper Butter.

Their succulent steaks, grilled to perfection, are a testament to their culinary expertise, while their savory pizzas, topped with fresh ingredients and baked in a wood-fired oven, offer a taste of Italy in the heart of Anna Maria Island.

Notes: Near Marriott, OK food, good soups

  • Rod and Reel Pier*

In the north end of Anna Maria Island, Rod & Reel Pier is a cherished island institution, offering an enticing blend of seaside charm, fresh seafood delicacies, and a touch of old-Florida nostalgia.

Since its inception in 1947, this beloved waterfront haven has captivated the hearts of locals and visitors alike, providing a taste of Anna Maria’s rich history alongside exceptional dining experiences.

The pier’s wooden structure, weathered by the elements and adorned with rustic fishing nets, exudes a unique charm that whispers tales of seafaring expeditions and cherished memories.

The menu features an abundance of fresh seafood, sourced directly from local fishermen and prepared with time-honored techniques that showcase the bounty of the Gulf. Indulge in their signature Coconut-Crusted Mahi Mahi, a delectable blend of crispy coconut, succulent fish, and a hint of tropical sweetness.

Beyond seafood, Rod & Reel Pier offers a variety of delectable options that cater to every palate. Their juicy burgers, prepared with fresh, never-frozen beef, are a favorite among diners of all ages. And, their crispy fish tacos, bursting with flavor and fresh ingredients, offer a taste of coastal cuisine.

Notes: Reasonable prices, location great waterfront

Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe
Kokonut Hut at Gulf Drive Cafe
  • Poppo’s Taqueria

Poppo’s Taqueria is a popular Mexican restaurant located on Anna Maria Island, Florida. Poppo’s is known for its casual and vibrant atmosphere, serving a variety of Mexican-inspired dishes.

Poppo’s is renowned for its tacos and burritos, offering a customizable menu where customers can choose from a variety of proteins, toppings, and sauces. This allows for a personalized dining experience to suit individual preferences.

Poppo’s is often praised for using fresh and high-quality ingredients in their dishes. The focus is on providing flavorful and authentic Mexican cuisine.

The restaurant typically maintains a laid-back and casual setting, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors looking for a relaxed dining experience.

Notes: Tacos are good, good little place

  • Anna Maria Island Beach Café

On the shores of Anna Maria Island, the Anna Maria Island Beach Café stands as a cherished island institution, offering an inviting blend of casual dining, stunning Gulf views, and a touch of local charm.

Since its inception in 1952, this beloved beachfront gem has garnered a reputation as a local favorite, consistently delivering a taste of the tropics with its fresh, flavorful cuisine and welcoming atmosphere.

Start your day with a hearty breakfast, indulging in fluffy omelets, golden pancakes, or crispy French toast, all prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. For lunch, savor the fresh flavors of the sea with their delectable fish tacos, juicy burgers, or refreshing salads, perfectly suited for a leisurely meal amidst the coastal ambiance.

And as the sun begins its descent, indulge in a satisfying dinner, choosing from a selection of grilled seafood platters, savory sandwiches, or their signature All-You-Can-Eat Fish Fry, a true island tradition.

Whether you’re seeking a casual beachfront lunch, a romantic sunset dinner, or a lively family gathering, the Anna Maria Island Beach Café seamlessly caters to every occasion.

One of the the candidates for the best breakfast on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: beachfront, entertainment, fun, beachy

  • Island Time Family Grille
Island Time Cafe Food

Island Time Bar and Grill, now known as the Island Time Family Grille, is a popular restaurant located on Bradenton Beach, which is part of Anna Maria Island in Florida.

Island Time Family Grille typically offers a casual and family-friendly dining atmosphere. It’s known for being a relaxed spot where visitors can enjoy a meal in a laid-back setting.

The restaurant’s menu often features a variety of dishes, including seafood, burgers, sandwiches, salads, and more. Many establishments on Anna Maria Island highlight fresh and locally sourced ingredients.

Notes: corner location, beach atmosphere, pub food

  • Gulf Drive Café

Situated right on the beachfront, Gulf Drive Cafe offers a perfect mix of casual dining, breathtaking views, and a touch of island history.

Located right on Gulf Drive North in Bradenton Beach, the Gulf Drive Cafe boasts direct access to sands and waters of the Gulf of Mexico. The expansive beachfront patio offers stunning sunset views, making it a popular spot for romantic dinners and leisurely lunches.

Established in 1981, the Gulf Drive Cafe has been a mainstay on Anna Maria Island for over four decades. Live music adds to the laid-back vibes, creating a fun and festive environment.

The menu features American classics with a focus on fresh seafood. Popular dishes include the fish and chips, grouper sandwiches, and burgers. You can also find salads, pizzas, and a selection of lighter options. The bar offers a variety of cocktails, beers, and wines, including specialty frozen drinks perfect for enjoying on the beachfront.

Gulf Drive Cafe is more than just a restaurant. The property also houses the Kokonut Hut, a full-service tiki bar with its own distinct island vibe. It’s a popular spot for enjoying tropical cocktails and soaking up the sun. 

Additionally, the Sunset by Gulf Drive Cafe caters to special events, providing a scenic space for weddings, receptions, and other celebrations. One of the most popular Anna Maria Island restaurants on the beach.

Notes: casual expansive bar on Gulf, Tiki Bar with views

Vinny's Italian Kitchen
Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier
  • Vinny’s Italian Kitchen

Vinny’s isn’t just a restaurant, it’s a labor of love from Chef Vincenzo, who hails from a family of Italian butchers and deli owners. He brings his passion and old-school Italian recipes to the table, ensuring fresh, flavorful dishes that transport you to the cobblestone streets of a charming Italian village.

While you can certainly find classic pizzas and pastas on the menu, Vinny’s goes beyond the expected. Think wood-fired pizzas with unique toppings, like the Caprese Bianca with prosciutto, mozzarella, and fresh basil, or the Pescatore, brimming with seafood. Pasta dishes like the Tagliatelle al Ragu di Cinghiale (wild boar ragu) or the Gnocchi al Pesto will tantalize your taste buds.

Vinny’s Italian Kitchen is a versatile spot. Start your day with fresh pastries and espresso from the bakery. Grab a panini or salad for a casual lunch. Savor a romantic dinner on the outdoor patio, complete with twinkling lights and live music. 

They even have a market stocked with Italian specialties like cheeses, meats, and olive oil, perfect for taking home a taste of Italy. One of Anna Maria Island’s best restaurants for Italian food.

Notes: Casual Italian, store also,

  • Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Marina

Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Pub is a well-known waterfront dining establishment located on Longboat Key, which is near Anna Maria Island in Florida.

Mar Vista is situated directly on the water, offering patrons picturesque views of Sarasota Bay. The restaurant provides an inviting setting for guests to enjoy their meals while taking in the scenic surroundings.

The restaurant is housed in a historic building that dates back to the early 20th century. The historic charm adds to the unique atmosphere, providing a blend of Old Florida architecture and coastal elegance.

Mar Vista is known for its diverse menu, featuring a mix of seafood, American cuisine, and tropical-inspired dishes. Fresh, locally sourced ingredients are often emphasized, especially in seafood offerings.

Given its waterfront location, Mar Vista typically offers outdoor seating options, allowing guests to dine al fresco and enjoy the sea breeze.

Mar Vista has been involved in sea turtle conservation efforts. The restaurant has implemented turtle-friendly lighting practices to protect nesting sea turtles along the coast. One of the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: upscale good pub food, great views on intra-coastal

  • The Anna Maria Oyster Bar*

The Anna Maria Oyster Bar is a popular chain of seafood restaurants with several locations on Anna Maria Island and beyond. It’s known for its lively atmosphere, casual dining, and of course, delicious fresh seafood.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar boasts a vibrant, fun atmosphere with nautical accents, giant fish tanks, and live music at some locations. It’s a great spot for a casual get-together with friends or family.

The menu features a wide range of seafood options, including raw oysters, steamed clams, shrimp cocktails, fish tacos, grilled fish platters, and more. They also have burgers, sandwiches, salads, and other non-seafood dishes for those who want something different.

The bar offers a great selection of beers, wines, cocktails, and their signature “Beach Brite” frozen drinks.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar has several locations on and near Anna Maria Island, including Bridge St. Pier, Cortez, Landside, and Ellenton. Each location has its own unique charm and atmosphere.

The restaurant offers daily and weekly specials, including discounted drinks, raw oysters, and other menu items. If you are looking for one of the best seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island, this is the place to go – with a view too!

Notes: Great place for specials, good seafood, on pier with views

  • The Chateau Anna Maria

The Chateau Anna Maria is a multifaceted gem on Anna Maria Island, offering a delightful blend of upscale waterfront dining, casual pub fare, and vibrant nightlife.

Chef Greg Long and his team have garnered national acclaim for their French-inspired cuisine at The Chateau Restaurant. Expect exquisite dishes prepared with fresh, seasonal ingredients and presented with artistry. The restaurant boasts an elegant ambiance with stunning waterfront views, making it perfect for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.

The Chateau doesn’t stop at food and drinks. They also have a Cigar Room for indulging in premium cigars, a fire pit for cozy evenings, and live music on weekends, providing a lively atmosphere for guests to relax and enjoy.

The Chateau Anna Maria is a popular venue for private events, from weddings and receptions to corporate gatherings and special occasions. They offer a variety of spaces, catering services, and event planning assistance to ensure a memorable experience. One of the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Notes: waterfront, upscale, good romantic location

Fun at The Freckled Fin
Cheesecakes at Hometown Desserts
  • Freckled Fin Irish Pub

Freckled Fin beckons with its warm glow and friendly vibes. Think cozy booths, wooden accents, and the ever-present twinkle of fairy lights, all creating a space that feels like stepping into a traditional Irish pub.

But the magic of Freckled Fin goes beyond its décor. It’s all about the spirit, the laughter, and the good times that flow like the Guinness on tap. Live music, often lively jigs and fiddle tunes, fills the air, turning even the most reserved landlubber into a foot-stomping reveler.

And speaking of revelry, the menu at Freckled Fin is a veritable feast for the senses. Think classic pub fare with an Irish twist: hearty shepherd’s pie, juicy bangers and mash, and fish and chips that practically melt in your mouth. Wash it all down with a pint of Guinness, a cider as crisp as the island breeze, or explore their unique selection of Irish whiskeys.

This is another place that if you are wondering where do the locals eat on Anna Maria Island, you found it.

Notes: true Irish pub, sports TVs, entertainment big

  • Hometown Desserts

Hometown Desserts is a haven for all things sweet and delicious, offering an irresistible array of cakes, pies, cookies, and more.

Hometown Desserts boasts a mouthwatering menu featuring classic favorites like carrot cake, brownies, cheesecakes, and pies, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. They also offer unique creations like their Key Lime Coconut cake, perfect for a taste of island flavor.

Looking for something special? Hometown Desserts specializes in custom cakes and cupcakes, expertly decorated to suit any occasion. From birthdays and weddings to graduations and baby showers, they’ll bring your dessert dreams to life.

Satisfy your caffeine cravings with a selection of coffee and espresso drinks. Pair your pastry with a hot latte or a refreshing iced tea for the perfect afternoon pick-me-up.

Hometown Desserts has two locations. The original store on Pine Ave in Bradenton and a newer location on Manatee Ave W in Holmes Beach. This makes it convenient to satisfy your sweet tooth no matter where you are on the island.

Notes: luscious desserts, great cheesecakes

  • The Waffle Press

The Waffle Press in Anna Maria Island is a delightful spot known for its Liege waffles, coffee, and beachy vibes. Forget your typical breakfast waffles!

The Waffle Press specializes in Liege waffles, a denser, caramelized Belgian style with pockets of pearl sugar that add a delightful crunch. They offer a variety of toppings to customize your waffle, from classics like strawberries

This post first appeared on Florida Travel Blog, please read the originial post: here

Share the post

Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island