In a world increasingly dominated by technology, the New York Police Department (NYPD) has made a multimillion-dollar investment in Social Media. But before you jump to conclusions, this isn't your typical browse through your aunt's vacation photos. The New York Police Department's social media journey includes sophisticated technologies, contentious contracts, and even a spice of judicial drama.

The High-Tech Trailblazers

Picture this: a bustling metropolis where the NYPD has spent millions of dollars on cutting-edge technology to keep a watchful eye on the digital world. They're not sitting behind computer screens sifting through endless cat videos. Instead, they've enlisted the services of Voyager Labs, a surveillance company claiming to utilize artificial intelligence to dissect online human behavior.

Voyager Labs' software works like a digital detective, sifting through massive digital databases at breakneck speed to assist law enforcement in uncovering fraudulent activities and predicting crimes. Consider Sherlock Holmes but with lines of code and algorithms instead of people. In 2018, the NYPD signed an eye-catching contract with Voyager Labs worth roughly $8.5 million, demonstrating their commitment to staying ahead in the tech game. Their digital adventure, however, has not been without criticism.

The Controversy Unveiled

Voyager Labs found themselves in hot water after Meta, then known as Facebook, sued them. What is the charge? Using around 40,000 fraudulent Facebook profiles to collect data from approximately 600,000 users. Yes, you read that correctly: colossal amounts of inappropriate data scraping. It's the digital equivalent of sneaking more candy than you're allowed on Halloween.

The Guardian once spilled the beans on Voyager Labs, portraying them as a software company that aids law enforcement in an eerie quest to surveil and scrutinize people by piecing together their entire digital lives. It's like putting together a puzzle, except instead of corners and edges, they're looking for your favorite memes and online buying patterns.

More Players in the Game

However, Voyager Labs is not the only company engaged in this digital cat-and-mouse game. The Queens district attorney has also joined the party, shaking hands with Israeli startup Cobwebs Technologies. Like Voyager Labs, Cobwebs Technologies is interested in social network mapping software. It's similar to having a GPS for your online presence, only that someone else is in charge of the map.

Now, it's essential to acknowledge that law enforcement agencies in the United States have a history of working with social media analytics firms. After all, there's a treasure trove of personal information online, just waiting to be discovered. But, and it's a big but, this practice must be executed with responsibility and legality in mind.

The Responsible Digital Pursuit

Experts advise that when police enter the digital sea, they must do so ethically and within the law. The alarm bells start ringing when they begin forecasting future criminal behaviors by peering into private information without the required documents (such as subpoenas and warrants).

Will Owen, the head of the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project (STOP), a privacy rights advocacy organization, doesn't mince words. According to Owen, these contracts with Voyager Labs and Cobwebs Technologies signify an expansion of law enforcement's use of social media monitoring and other comprehensive surveillance techniques. Historically, these techniques disproportionately targeted Black and Latinx New Yorkers, especially children. It's intrusive and disturbing, and Owen believes it should be prohibited.

A Constitutionally Gray Area

To add a layer of complexity, Voyager Labs allows its clients to create fake social media profiles to harvest data that would otherwise be off-limits. This irked Meta so much that they decided to take legal action against Voyager in January 2023, demanding a permanent ban from Facebook and Instagram.

Now, the NYPD's use of Voyager software is a digital mystery. It is worth mentioning, however, that their officers are legally able to work under the guise of bogus social media profiles. According to Liz Huang, STOP's civil rights intern, "with every friend and follow request you accept, you risk a covert cop invading your privacy." It's similar to a hide-and-seek game but with far more significant stakes.

A Beacon of Hope

To combat this digital wild west, STOP is championing the "Stop Online Police Fake Accounts and Keep Everyone Safe" (STOP FAKES) Bill in New York State. This groundbreaking legislation prohibits law enforcement from leveraging fake social media accounts to surveil New Yorkers. It's like setting up an impenetrable fortress to safeguard digital privacy.

In this ever-changing world of technology and surveillance, striking a balance between security and individual rights is critical. While intriguing and, at times, perplexing, the NYPD's venture into the digital arena raises crucial concerns about where the line should be set in the digital sand. As we progress in this technologically advanced era, let us hope that the watchful eye of justice remains as attentive as ever while respecting the bounds of our digital life.


Read next: New Warning Issued Against Smart Devices Collecting More User Data Than Required