Now that we have witnessed the euphoria surrounding Worldcoin with people queuing to get their irises scanned and the crowd going berserk, leading to a shut down of all three initial locations of orb operations in Bengaluru last Friday, let’s explore the big picture for Worldcoin in India.
Drawing parallels to the government-organised large-scale biometric scan that began 12 years ago, which also claimed to create a unique digital identity and provide benefits to citizens via welfare schemes, it looks like Worldcoin may not be too different from Aadhaar — but it is!
India Leading The Way
Former chief economist of World Bank, Paul Romer referred to Aadhaar as the most “sophisticated system” he had ever seen, and considered it to be “good for the world if this became widely adopted”. As a prelude to organisations planning to adopt similar mechanisms, it is not surprising that Worldcoin also took inspiration from Aadhaar. In their 2021 blog that launched Worldcoin, the company mentioned that biometric approaches for proof of personhood is an accessible method and allows accurate verification of uniqueness, calling out parallels to Aadhaar in India.
Though they admitted to challenges related to privacy and fraud detection, the company believes latest advancements can solve it.
While another method to approach proof-of-personhood is through the social-graph method, with a number of companies already adopting such a technique, scalability challenges impede its adoption. For a project like Worldcoin, biometric was the viable option. OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, in his last visit to India, appreciated India’s efforts in building and adopting technology, with a special mention to Aadhaar and UPI systems that emerged here.
With an ambitious goal of 1 billion signups, Worldcoin announced their grand project two years ago. As of now, they have achieved over 2 million sign ups and counting. Interestingly, within five-and-a-half years, Aadhaar clocked 1 billion registrations.
India Unperturbed by Worldcoin
Though the goals for both projects are vaguely similar, the modus operandi are different. Creation of digital identity is one of the goals for Worldcoin, crypto tokens being another. On successful completion of the biometric scan, Worldcoin offers 25 ‘World tokens’ (WLD). Each WLD is a little over $2. While the broader goal of the company is to distribute wealth generated by AI back to society, the timeline to implement this goal is uncertain and will probably fall in the distant future.
Furthermore, being a private organisation, no form of enforcement can be implemented, unless a government affiliation or law comes into the picture — which obviously means that the distribution of universal basic income will not come to fruition. However, Aadhaar has no such obstacles. Though not mandatory, in order to avail welfare schemes, individuals need to possess an Aadhaar card. As per the Economic Survey 2023, 318 Central schemes and over 720 state DBT (Direct Benefit Transfer) schemes come under Aadhaar Act, and these are facilitated via Aadhaar cards.
In this grand scheme of things, where Aadhaar is functioning like a well-oiled machine, Worldcoin will not hold a candle to it.
Rising Mutiny
While Worldcoin is making its way across the globe with setting up orb scanning locations across 20 countries (35 cities), not all has been rosy for the company. Investigations and watchful scrutiny has risen regarding Worldcoin operations. Yesterday, Kenya became the first country to ban Worldcoin operations owing to security and financial concerns. The suspension of Worldcoin also applies to other entities that operate in a similar fashion that “engage the people of Kenya”. It will not operate until the authorities ascertain there is no form of risk to the public, as they are looking into how and what would be done with people’s data. However, the orb locations across Kenya witnessed throngs of people.
Within a week of its launch, UK and European regulators were quick to jump onto the scrutiny train. Countries including France and Germany have started investigating its operations over concerns of collecting sensitive biometric data. It’s not surprising that the EU, known for having stringent data regulatory policies in the world, will scrutinise the project, but it’s strange that they are looking into it after it’s been launched.
With countries waking up to rigorous scrutiny, it looks like India might follow the regulatory scrutiny too. Besides, with Aadhaar already in place and pretty much meeting the goals of ambitious Worldcoin, why have it here in India?
The post Why Do You Need Worldcoin When You Have Aadhaar? appeared first on Analytics India Magazine.
