With 10 seconds left, Robert Phinisee pushed IU into a set designed to find Romeo Langford.
They turned the ball over too much, allowed Butler too many offensive rebounds, looked like they'd spent up all their close-game karma.
Indiana made just one of its first five shots, let Butler get comfortable on the offensive glass and fell behind by as many as 11 in the opening 20 minutes.
The sensational freshman only attempted one shot in his first 10 minutes, and generally struggled to find his offensive rhythm against Butler’s man-to-man.
His inside and outside game caused Butler match-up problems, and even when the Bulldogs got their big men on him, he still made it work.
- Watch: Indiana's Rob Phinisee hits 3-point buzzer-beater to defeat Butler in ...NCAA.com
- Buzzer breakdown: Butler falls to No. 25 IU on last-second shotIndianapolis Star
- Buzzer breakdown: Last-second shot by Rob Phinisee lifts IU over Butler in ...Indianapolis Star
- Instant Recap: IU men's basketball beats Butler on winning shot by Rob PhiniseeIndiana Daily Student
- Twitter reacts to Rob Phinisee's buzzer-beater to help IU basketball beat ButlerIndianapolis Star
- How to Watch Indiana vs Butler Basketball Online Without CableHeavy.com
- At the buzzer: Indiana 71, Butler 68Inside the Hall
- Buzzer-beating 3 sends No. 25 Indiana past Butler 71-68Minneapolis Star Tribune
- Pregame: Indiana (8-2) vs. Butler (7-2)Fort Wayne Journal Gazette