Now that you’re a proud owner of a Keurig Coffee maker, the only thing missing is your supply of dark roast k-cup. But one look at the range and variety of options is enough to make even veteran coffee drinkers overwhelmed.

Whether you’re looking for a new brand to try or the best dark roast coffees, we rounded up some of the most highly-recommended coffee k cups. From the flavor and value, down to the type of coffee beans used and pack size, you’ll have all the info you’ll need to find your perfect match. So sit back and sip your cup of joe while scrolling down this coffee rabbit hole.