Back in the day, Wells Adams vied for JoJo Fletcher’s affection on her season of The Bachelorette, but she sent him home during their one-on-one date. Adams and Hyland’s love story all commenced on Twitter with many thanks to a Harry Potter reference that Adams made about fellow competitor Chad Johnson. Adams joined Bachelor in Paradise as the much-adored bartender (never forget his “scallop fingers” reenactment) and his relationship with Hyland went full-force after. Adams moved to Los Angeles from Nashville over the summer, and the two of them continue to be the some of the funniest and realest couples around. They also recently got engaged!

Lauren Bushnell won Ben Higgins’ season of The Bachelor, but the couple parted ways in 2017 after about a year (his season aired in the beginning of 2016). After dating businessman Devin Antin, Bushnell has since started dating country music singer Chris Lane. The two of them posed on the red carpet together in November at the 66th Annual BMI Country Awards in Nashville. They then arrived at the 2018 Country Music Awards together and continue to post cute Instagram photos together. They also are getting ready to tie the knot.

Before being the main man in Bachelor Mansion, Colton Underwood dated Olympic gymnast and advocate Aly Raisman. The former football pro asked her out in a cute video and then their Twitter flirting became the real thing. They hit the red carpet together in 2016 at the Sports Illustrated Sportsperson of the Year Ceremony a few months after the video. Raisman and Underwood split in 2017.

This duo’s an example of hearsay. After flirting a bit on social media, the former Mad Men star told the world that she wasn’t actually dating Viall. Jones called him a “friend of mine” and said that she was single. 

This one is merely a capital-R Rumor. After his season of The Bachelor, Ben Flajnik was seen hanging out with KarJenner matriarch Kris Jenner in 2013. Rumors of their romance began to swirl, but Kris quickly put the kibosh on it. “Ben and I are good friends,” she said in an exclusive statement to E! News at the time. “I think he is a great guy but we aren’t dating!”

The John Tucker Must Die star had a bit of a fling with Ben Flajnik’s ex-fiancée Courtney Robertson. They met in 2004 apparently and she wrote all about their romance in her book I Didn’t Come Here to Make Friends: Confessions of a Reality Show Villain. This photo of them together was taken in 2005. While she provided some, uh, not PG-rated details in her book about her trysts (she was also apparently involved with Adrian Grenier and Gerard Butler), Metcalfe didn’t really care to comment about their relationship. In 2014, he told Huffington Post, “I don’t want to help her writing career more than I already have.”

Chase McNary made it really far during JoJo Fletcher’s season of The Bachelorette, but she sent him home and ended up engaged to Jordan Rodgers. Since departing The Bachelorette, McNary has appeared on other reality shows, including MTV’s Ex on the Beach. He had a brief fling with pro golfer Chelsea Lynn Pezzola as well as conservative TV commentator Tomi Lahren. He told Us Weekly in January 2017 of Lahren, “We were talking for about two weeks, but we weren’t in the same place, so we went our separate ways.”