Why Do People Dislike Hatchery Raised Trout

Years ago, there were a lot of negative things associated with hatchery raised trout. In the days of old, diseases, viruses and other nasties were linked to hatchery raised trout. But in present times, a lot of effort has been made to keep these farmed fish disease free, making them a much more desirable game fish.

​
More Differences Between Hatchery Trout And Wild Trout

There's no question that wild trout have many more desirable traits that fishermen want compared to hatchery fish.  Some of the main differences between hatchery raised and wild trout are:

• Hatchery trout are much less wary
• They're easier to catch by both fishermen and predators
• Hatchery trout are weaker fighters when caught
• Less acrobatic on the end of the fishing line.

How To Identify Hatchery Raised Trout

Clipped Adipose Fin

The easiest way to identify hatchery raised trout is to look closely at their adipose fin. Hatchery raised trout will have a clipped adipose fin.  You can tell that the adipose fin is clipped because in its place will be a healed scar. 

These fins are clipped while the trout are still juveniles living in the fish hatchery.  Each one is clipped by hand by a hatchery worker.  By clipping this fin, anyone who catches the fish later in its life will immediately be able to know if its a wild trout or a hatchery raised and released trout.

Worn Pectoral Fins

Unfortunately, sometimes a trout will sneak through the hatchery fin clipping process and released into the wild.  Without a clipped adipose fin it's a lot more difficult to identify a hatchery raised fish. 

In these cases, there's another thing you can look at.  And that is the fish's pectoral fins.  In some cases, the pectoral fins of hatchery raised trout will be ragged and worn out.  This is a result of the fish swimming and remaining at the bottom of the concrete fish pond at the hatchery.  

Over time, these fins rub against the concrete walls and tear them up and wear them down.  While many times fish will recover from this, there are times when these pectoral fins never repair themselves.  

So if you catch a trout that still has it's adipose fin intact, but has very ragged pectoral fins, chances are you have a hatchery raised trout.

Genetic Contamination

Another issue fishermen have with hatchery raised trout is the potential for genetic contamination.  Believe it or not, when hatchery trout breed with wild trout, their offspring tend to be less capable of surviving the same environment.

Hatcheries Are A Necessity

The fact is, if there's to be a trout fishery, hatcheries have no other choice than to stock streams and lakes that that don't provide the environment trout need to reproduce naturally.

Keeper sized trout continue to be planted into these streams and lakes to keep up with the high demand there is to catch them. But even as this practice continues, the trend is actually beginning to change.

In recent years, the trend has been changing from planting keeper sized fish to planting younger sized fry or fingerlings. The hope is that these small trout will grow up in the streams they're planted in and adapt significantly more to the environment than if they grew up in a hatchery.

This new philosophy of introducing hatchery trout at a young age is significantly less expensive and the fish when caught closely resemble their wild trout counterparts.

How Long Do Hatchery Trout Live?

According to this 2018 research study on the survival rate of stocked trout in rivers and streams, less than 60% of the hatchery fish that were stocked survived past the first week. The study also found that a few of the trout that were stocked in the fall survived long enough to be available to anglers the following summer.    

How Long Do Wild Trout Live?

According to Streamexplorers.org, "Trout can live for about seven years. Most trout are born, grow up, lay eggs and die in lakes or streams. Some trout, though, become very large migratory fish and travel more in their seven years than some people do in a lifetime."

Final Thoughts

For more information on identifying different species of trout, because there are many....check out my post, How To Identify Trout: Tips For Identifying Different Kinds Of Trout Species.

Or for a look a 5 classic trout baits that are guaranteed to work, read 5 Best Trout Baits For Catching More Fish.

Are you a trout fisherman?  What are your thoughts on catching hatchery fish?  Leave a comment below.  Would be interested in hearing your opinion.

Related Posts:

1. The Ultimate Guide To Fishing Reels (Types, Uses, Pros and Cons)

2. Review: Okuma Ceymar Spinning Reel (A Great Spinning Reel Under $50)

3. The Best Braided Fishing Line For Spinning Reels

4. Best Monofilament Fishing Line For Spinning Reels (Top 5)

5. The Best Spinning Rod Under $50