Not long ago, this 25-year-old man and his ex, Jane, 23, ended their relationship.

Currently, he lives with his parents, while Jane lives in an on-campus dorm at her college, which is an hour away from him. So, while they dated, she had some of her stuff at his parents’ house.

The job he has right now pays well, and since he saved a lot of money by living with his parents, he was able to spend a lot of money on gifts for Jane. He often bought her nice Jewelry.

Jane’s style wasn’t too extravagant, so the jewelry he bought wasn’t outrageously expensive. However, he’d bought a lot of the pieces while at markets that he and Jane would visit while taking trips around the country, and most of the jewelry they found was handcrafted.

When he and Jane broke up, she came over to his place to get all her belongings that were still there, and she asked that he make sure not to be home while she was there, which he didn’t have a problem with.

“But I did notice when I got back that she left behind her jewelry box full of trinkets. I promptly sent her a photo of the open box, asking if she wanted me to either ship it or drop it off. I got back a really rude response. It was something along the lines of, ‘I don’t want anything that reminds me of the time I wasted with you.’ It was really hurtful given that it was a mutual split, but whatever,” he said.

Even though none of the jewelry was expensive, he didn’t want to throw any of it away. So, he decided to allow his younger sisters, 8 and 11, to look through the jewelry and keep what they wanted. He planned to most likely donate the remaining pieces to a shelter.

“My 8-year-old sister, Julie, really liked an opal Butterfly Necklace from the box. And by really liked it, I mean she loves it. She hasn’t taken it off since she put it on and keeps coming out with the cutest ‘thank yous.’ She even made me a little thank you card at school with butterflies on them. It’s no secret that I have a real soft spot for my sisters, and why wouldn’t I? They’re beautiful girls,” he explained.

Yesterday, Jane called him, and she was acting completely different than she had been through text when he was asking her about her jewelry box. Jane apologized for what she said, acknowledging that it had been really cruel.

Sign up for Chip Chick’s newsletter and get stories like this delivered to your inbox.

After that, she said that she changed her mind and would like to have the jewelry box back, along with all of the pieces that were in it.

Since he hadn’t yet donated the jewelry box with the remaining pieces, he told her that she could have it back but let her know that his two sisters had taken a few of the pieces of jewelry that they wanted to keep for themselves.

“She asked about the butterfly necklace. I told her that Julie had it now and loved it. My ex got really upset that I would ‘give away her things’ and asked if I could get my sister to return the necklace. I actually went downstairs and saw Julie happily playing with her butterfly necklace on, and couldn’t do it,” he shared.

Once he realized that he didn’t want to break Julie’s heart by taking away the butterfly necklace, he called Jane back and said that she could still have the jewelry box back with all of the remaining jewelry but that he wasn’t taking away any of the jewelry from his sisters that they’d decided to keep. This meant that he wasn’t returning the butterfly necklace to Jane.

In response, Jane called him a jerk before hanging up the phone.

Now, she’s texting and saying awful things, and so is her sister.

Do you think he did the right thing by not returning Jane’s butterfly necklace?

You can read the original post on Reddit here.

If true crime defines your free time, this is for you: join Chip Chick’s True Crime Tribe

Legend Has It That She Haunts The Golden Gate Park, And You Shouldn’t Be Anywhere Near Stow Lake At Night

She Walked Out Of A First Date After A Guy Berated Her For Not Wanting To Have Kids

She Got Up And Left Her Own Wedding In Tears After Her Parents Humiliated Her During Their Speech

She’s Worried That Her Preschooler Son Is Showing Psychopathic Signs

In 1977, She Left Her New Job At A Law Firm To Run Some Errands During Her Lunch Break And Was Never Seen Or Heard From Again

Want To Deer-Proof Your Garden? Here Are 10 Shrubs That Deer Won’t Dine On

She Wrote The Beloved Childhood Story “The Tale Of Peter Rabbit,” And Worldwide, Over 250 Million Copies Of This Classic Have Been Sold