Albus Dumbledore served one of the most crucial roles in the Harry Potter franchise — but the character was recast after the second movie, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Dumbledore was initially played by Irish actor Richard Harris in the first two Harry Potter movies. Following the second installment, Dumbledore was recast, and here’s why.
When the role of the Hogwarts Headmaster was initially being cast ahead of 2001’s Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, actors Patrick McGoohan and Sean Connery were targeted for the part. The key role eventually went to Harris, and the actor expected to play the part throughout the entire film franchise. He initially hesitated to take the role due to his health, but Harris was encouraged by his young granddaughter. Harris perfectly embodied the exceptional wizard and Harry’s mentor in the first two installments of the franchise.
Prior to the release of Chamber of Secrets in November 2002, Harris’ health took a turn for the worse. After being hospitalized with an illness, Harris was diagnosed with Hodgkin’s lymphoma. He remained upbeat and told Alfonso Cuarón, the director of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, not to recast his part.
Why Harry Potter Recast Dumbledore
Despite his hopes to return as Dumbledore, the actor sadly passed away from Hodgkin’s lymphoma a few months later at the age of 72. The Harry Potter film series was then tasked with recasting the role of Dumbledore in the hopes that the next actor could stick around for the remainder of the franchise. Harris’ tenure as Dumbledore was iconic and tragically brief, and recasting the role was a delicate process that required a great deal of care and attention to ensure the cinematic change was as smooth as possible.
The Process Of Recasting Dumbledore For The Harry Potter Franchise
Cuarón and the rest of the Harry Potter crew spent months trying to refill the role of Dumbledore for Prisoner of Azkaban — and beyond. A number of popular and established actors almost played Albus Dumbledore, including Christopher Lee, who was a top pick but couldn’t commit due to scheduling conflicts. Fellow Lord of the Rings star Ian McKellen was also considered but felt uncomfortable taking the role due to his rocky relationship with Harris. After Peter O’Toole’s age and health status became worrisome, the producers went with Michael Gambon as Harris’ official replacement as Dumbledore.
Gambon, another Irish-born actor, played Dumbledore for the remaining six films in the Harry Potter series. His portrayal became one of the actor’s best-known roles, but his version of the character was drastically different than his predecessor. This threw many viewers off at first, but his prominence and longevity in the franchise won fans over. The actor decided early on that he wouldn’t try to copy Harris’ performance and, instead, made Dumbledore his own. The circumstances were unfortunate, but Gambon stepped up in a time of need and gave the beloved book character a special on-screen counterpart right up to Dumbledore’s iconic death in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince.
Why Michael Gambon Wasn’t In The Harry Potter Reunion
Despite having taken on the iconic role of Dumbledore, Michael Gambon was conspicuous in his absence in the reunion special Harry Potter 20th Anniversary: Return to Hogwarts. Sadly, it’s believed that Gambon’s absence was due to his poor health, too, as the actor reported in 2015 that he had begun to have difficulty with memory loss, and it was affecting his ability to act. This hasn’t been officially confirmed, and no official reason was given for Gambon’s absence in Return to Hogwarts, but the lack of Dumbledore in the Harry Potter Reunion was something that disappointed many fans.
- Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore (2022)Release date: Apr 15, 2022
About The Author
