I know both are Aventus clones, and both are similarly ranked and ive read that CDNI is more smokey and L'Aventure is more fruity (which i prefer..especially during summer) Ive read both are pretty much the 1 and 2 closest to Aventus but which is the better smell overall...without comparing to aventus?

Im leaning towards buying L'aventure bc it is an EDP so it should be longer lasting and bc its considered more fruity/citrusy..which i think would prefer to being more smokey.

I have never actually smelled aventus but have smelled a roll on oil clone i bought from etsy and loved the smell. My only concern is reading that the CDNI is smokey...does it still remain a light fragrance?