In a shocking turn of events, Joe Jonas and Sophie Turner, known for their respective careers in the music and entertainment industries, have announced their divorce after four years of marriage and the birth of two children. The couple took to Instagram on September 6 to confirm the news, putting an end to rampant speculation fueled by photos of the pair without their wedding bands and media reports hinting at their impending split. However, what’s raising eyebrows among fans is the narrative surrounding their divorce, which seems to be painting Sophie Turner in an unfair light.

On Tuesday, September 5, several media outlets reported that Joe Jonas had filed for divorce in Florida, requesting joint custody of their two children, three-year-old Willa and their one-year-old daughter, Her name remains undisclosed to the general public.

TMZ, in particular, shed light on the alleged reasons behind the divorce, quoting an unnamed source claiming that “she likes to party, he likes to stay at home. They have very different lifestyles.” The same report suggested that the couple’s children had been living with Jonas for the past three months while he was on tour with the Jonas Brothers, while Sophie Turner had been in London for work.

Joe Jonas and Sophie Turner addressed the divorce rumors themselves by posting an identical statement on Instagram on September 6. Their statement emphasized that the decision to divorce was mutual and requested privacy for themselves and their children: “After four wonderful years of marriage, we have mutually decided to amicably end our marriage. Amidst the various speculations surrounding our decision, it is essential to clarify that this is a mutual choice, and we wholeheartedly hope for understanding and respect for our desire for privacy, especially concerning our children.

However, what has fueled fans’ skepticism is the timing of their public statements and the way the narrative around the split has been constructed.

Fans immediately recalled an interview with Sophie Turner from 2020, where she mentioned that she is more of a homebody, contrasting Joe Jonas’s social nature. In the interview with Conan O’Brien, Turner said, “I’m an introvert. I’m a homebody. I’m just like, if I could stay home all day, I would, so this is great for me.” This interview seems to contradict the narrative of her as a hardcore partier.

Furthermore, fans unearthed a TikTok video from 2020 in which Joe Jonas and Sophie Turner answered questions about their relationship, both agreeing that Turner is the partner who prefers to stay at home. This stands in stark contrast to the reports suggesting that Joe likes to stay home, while Sophie likes to party.

Given Sophie Turner’s “homebody” comments, the unnamed source’s claim that Joe Jonas initiated the divorce due to her partying, and the fact that the children have been with him recently, some fans have concluded that Joe and his team might be intentionally trying to tarnish Sophie’s reputation.

Comments on Joe Jonas’s Instagram post from September 4, where he prominently displayed his wedding band, reflect this sentiment. One commenter accused him of posting the picture “just before filing for divorce and publicly throwing Sophie under the bus.” Another commenter criticized him for trying to make the mother of his children look bad.

On Twitter, fans pointed out the inconsistencies in the narrative, with one user noting, “Joe Jonas’ team saying that he’s the homebody and Sophie parties too much, but then a Rediscovered on TikTok was a video they had created together, where both of them concurred that she was the homebody – it’s clear, Joe, the numbers just don’t add up.”

In a surprising twist, TMZ published another report on September 6, claiming that sources with direct contact with Joe Jonas had revealed that the decision to file for divorce came after he saw something on a Ring security camera. However, the report provided no further details about what exactly was captured on the camera.

The Joe Jonas-Sophie Turner divorce story has captivated the public’s attention, with fans expressing doubt about the narrative being presented by some media outlets and Joe Jonas’s camp. As speculation continues to swirl, one thing remains clear: the truth behind their divorce is more complex than initially suggested. Only time will reveal the full story, and in the meantime, fans and the public are left to speculate and discuss the details that have surfaced so far.