Yellowstone, the popular Western TV series, has garnered both acclaim and criticism for its portrayal of Native Americans. The show, which premiered in 2018, revolves around the Dutton family, with Kevin Costner playing the role of patriarch John Dutton. While it has achieved record-breaking ratings and spawned multiple spinoffs, it has also faced backlash for its depiction of Indigenous communities. In a recent interview with Vulture, Lily Gladstone, the star of Martin Scorsese’s upcoming film “Killers of the Flower Moon,” shared her thoughts on “Yellowstone” and the challenges faced by Native American actors in the industry.
Lily Gladstone did not mince words when describing her views on “Yellowstone.” She used words like “delusional” and “deplorable” to characterize the show’s portrayal of Native Americans. Gladstone, who is of Blackfeet and Nez Perce descent on her father’s side and white on her mother’s side, expressed her disappointment with the series but emphasized that she does not blame the Native American cast members for accepting roles in the show. She recognized the scarcity of opportunities for Native American actors in the entertainment industry, making it difficult for them to turn down roles when offered.
Gladstone’s critique of “Yellowstone” is not isolated. Other Native critics have also voiced their concerns about the show’s depiction of Indigenous people. In a 2022 article for High Country News, Liza Black, a member of the Cherokee Nation and a professor of Native American and Indigenous Studies, criticized the series for perpetuating stereotypes and erasing the complex history between Native Americans and settlers. Black also raised concerns about the show’s graphic violence against Native women.
On the flip side, some Native individuals involved in the show have defended it, citing the opportunity to portray Native facts and empower their characters within the storyline. Crow Nation tribal chairman AJ Not Afraid mentioned that the show allowed them to showcase some Native truths and beliefs. Gil Birmingham, a Native American actor on the show, praised creator Taylor Sheridan for crafting empowered characters and addressing important issues like corporate greed and the gentrification of the West.
“Killers of the Flower Moon” – A Different Perspective
Lily Gladstone’s upcoming film, “Killers of the Flower Moon,” offers a contrast to her views on “Yellowstone.” The movie, based on David Grann’s 2017 book, explores the real-life murders of Osage Nation members in the 1920s following the discovery of oil on their reservation. Initially, the script focused more on a government agent investigating the murders. However, Gladstone revealed that rewrites were undertaken to place greater emphasis on the Osage community’s perspective, turning it into a story that is not a “white-savior” narrative.
Gladstone’s involvement in the film was not limited to acting; she was encouraged to contribute her insights and was joined by members of the Osage community in shaping the narrative. This collaborative approach, as she noted, represents true equity in filmmaking, where Native voices are not just given a seat at the table but also actively included in the storytelling process.
Lily Gladstone’s candid critique of “Yellowstone” sheds light on the ongoing challenges of Native American representation in the entertainment industry. While some individuals involved in the show defend its portrayal of Native Americans, others, including Gladstone, highlight the need for more authentic and sensitive depictions. “Killers of the Flower Moon” serves as a promising example of a film that prioritizes the voices and perspectives of Native communities, showcasing a more equitable approach to storytelling. As the industry continues to evolve, it’s crucial to address these concerns and work towards a more inclusive and respectful representation of Indigenous cultures in media.
