Whatever food you might personally love or loathe, you can’t deny that cooking can be an immense pleasure. Though you’ve got to get all the groceries, do the prep work, and finish things off by washing a mountain of dishes, there’s hardly a better feeling than tucking into a dish you made yourself. And if your loved ones enjoy it as well—mission accomplished!

However, let’s be frank: we can’t always tell if our dish worked out. Sometimes, we need a bit of objectivity. One place where you can ask for an open and honest opinion is the ‘Rate My Plate’ Facebook group. Home to 40.1k members, the group invites people to share photos of their food and have it rated by others. You might get a metaphorical gold star for your delish dish… or you might get called an idiot sandwich.

We’ve collected some of the finest and weirdest dishes to show you, dear Pandas, and we’d love your verdict. Would you eat it? Would you avoid it even if you had a ten-foot pole? Scroll down, upvote your fave photos, and share your honest opinions in the comments.

Bored Panda has reached out to the ‘Rate My Plate’ team, and we’ll update the article once we hear back from them.

#1

Image credits: Gavin Barrass Armstrong

#2

Image credits: Morgan Cassie

#3

Image credits: Gavin Barrass Armstrong

The ‘Rate My Plate’ Facebook group celebrated its second birthday a few months ago. The public group was founded in mid-August 2020, and welcomes members from all over the globe, so long as they promise to follow the rules.

One of the main rules that everyone ought to follow is to set their egos aside. “The group is meant for comments to be made on people’s food so don’t get offended if somebody says something bad about your food,” the team running the show explains. They add that anyone “caught being a snowflake” will end up suspended.

#4

Image credits: Lee Davidson

#5

Image credits: Jacob Grillot

#6

Image credits: Sally Hope

At the same time, members of the group are encouraged to be kind to each other. Criticism should never grow into something more, like bullying or degrading comments.

Keep it all food-related, and there shouldn’t be any problem. Post something unrelated to gastronomy, on the other hand, and you might find yourself suspended for a couple of days. The rules are pretty simple to follow, to be fair, and all you have to do is be a decent human being and talk about food pics. Sounds easy, right? At the time of writing, the Facebook group was run by a team of three administrators and one moderator.

#7

Image credits: Victoria Odonovan

#8

Image credits: Charis Doak

#9

Image credits: Gavin Barrass Armstrong

Cooking, pretty much like any other skill, relies on a person’s ability to focus and learn from their mistakes. Sure, some people might be ‘naturals’ and quickly move on to making complex dishes while the rest of us are stuck looking at our sad scrambled eggs. However, pretty much everyone has the ability to improve.

How much improvement you’ll see really depends on the time you spend in the kitchen and how willing you are to apply the lessons you learned when you failed, massively. Having someone to bounce your cooking ideas off of is absolutely great. Getting them to taste your culinary concoctions is even better.

#10

Image credits: Selina Mccloud

#11

Image credits: Connie Lynn

#12

Image credits: Nadia Susan Jackson

Broadly speaking, cooking is made up of two (arguably, unequal) parts. On the one hand, you have the taste. It’s the essence of cooking and will make or break absolutely any dish.

Even if everything looks delicious, the effort wasn’t worth it if the person eating your food ends up disappointed. Personally, we’ve tasted so many meals that look gorgeous but are bland/oversalted/overwhelmingly garlicky. And it ruins the entire experience.

#13

Image credits: Kelly Kidd

#14

Image credits: Faith Hoover

#15

Image credits: Rob Coduri

On the other hand, you have everything related to aesthetics and presentation. And that’s really the docs of the ‘Rate My Plate’ Facebook group. We don’t have the smell and taste to go on, so we’re left to make judgment calls using just one sense: our sight.

And here, things get tricky. We think that you’ll agree that many of us have seen horrible-looking dishes that actually tasted wonderful. But, on the flip side, we've also tasted tiny, beautiful dishes that work as art, but not as food.

#16

Image credits: Brendon D Mullen

#17

Image credits: Morely Howard

#18

Image credits: Rich Swift

It’s actually very hard to judge a meal by just the visuals because some weird flavor combinations can definitely work while others are bound to fall flat. For instance, Bored Panda previously looked at various weird vintage recipes. And though they sound extremely peculiar to us in the 21st century, some flavor combinations actually work quite nicely.

#19

Image credits: Doug Canham

#20

Image credits: Jane Harris

#21

Image credits: Amanda Williams

For example, Professor Nathalie Cooke, from McGill University, explained to us during an earlier interview that vintage party food recipes from the 1950s are the result of food fashion, but weren’t just a fad.

“That is, the basic flavor combination is something that reaches across the decades. What you’re describing may seem very odd to us in the 21st century, but the taste combinations—savory and sweet (tuna waffles, ham and bananas) or sweet and sour (mayo with lime) are surely very familiar,” she explained to us earlier.

#22

Image credits: Andy Rue

#23

Image credits: Gerda Thomas

#24

Image credits: Marc Wilco Wilcock

“There were ‘fads’ at mid-century: think of cookbooklets demonstrating how to decorate one’s ham with slices of canned pineapple, topped with the bedazzling red of a maraschino cherry, for example! And you don’t mention the jaw-dropping recipes incorporating marshmallows in main course dishes, recipes that were brain children of corporate marketing departments,” the professor said.

#25

Image credits: Raymond Leighton

#26

Image credits: Andy Sutcliffe

#27

Image credits: Petrou Vasilios

“But if we were to create one of today’s favorites from scratch, say Pad Thai, we would start from the same basic taste combinations you describe in what at first glance seem like bizarre plate partners,” she told Bored Panda before.

#28

Image credits: John Cooney

#29

Image credits: Chris Suter

#30

Image credits: Susan Brockbank

“Cooking bitter tamarind with water, raw sugar and fish sauce will build the basic foundation (sour, salty and sweet). To that one would add the requisite green onions, bean sprouts, and noodles—and likely some additional flavor notes such as shallot, garlic, and perhaps dried turnip (salty and sweet) to deepen the flavor.”

In other words, tasting the dish is paramount. And we’d love to try most of the food in this list, just to see if they taste as good as—or better than—we imagine.

#31

Image credits: Vicky Keen

#32

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#33

Image credits: David A Bain

#34

Image credits: Doug Skordas

#35

Image credits: Andrew Dalgarno

#36

Image credits: Sean Mclaughlin

#37

Image credits: Andy Rue

#38

Image credits: Mark Royle

#39

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#40

Image credits: Matt Gallo

#41

Image credits: Geoff Richards

#42

Image credits: Tony Coucom

#43

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#44

Image credits: Pablo Ellis

#45

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#46

Image credits: Lucy Natasha Bryant

#47

Image credits: Tan Tan

#48

Image credits: Michael Kirk

#49

Image credits: Claire Louise Partridge

#50

Image credits: Lenia Nascimento

#51

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#52

Image credits: Tommy Harbord

#53

Image credits: Adrian Smithy

#54

Image credits: Gary Moondoggy Lewis

#55

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#56

Image credits: Gavin Barrass Armstrong

#57

Image credits: Lilian Cordwell

#58

Image credits: Scott Buchanan

#59

Image credits: Sarah Francis

#60

Image credits: Jason Huhn

#61

Image credits: Anna Nguyen

#62

Image credits: Talisha Ann

#63

Image credits: Tom Brearley

#64

Image credits: Devlin Devo Mark

#65

Image credits: Amanda Williams

#66

Image credits: Teresa Marie

#67

Image credits: Andy Rue

#68

Image credits: Robert Miles Hayes

#69

Image credits: Barry Reed

#70

Image credits: Tony Hughes

#71

Image credits: Gilly Walsh

#72

Image credits: Dean Clark

#73

Image credits: Joseph Meehan

#74

Image credits: Barry Reed

#75

Image credits: Ellen Bruce-van Renswoude

#76

Image credits: Logan Anselm

#77

Image credits: Nikki Hackleton

#78

Image credits: Kim Ye

#79

Image credits: David Arundel

#80

Image credits: Logan Anselm

#81

Image credits: Gavin Barrass Armstrong

#82

Image credits: Lindsay Joyce

#83

Image credits: Scott Buchanan

#84

Image credits: Ace Shively

#85

Image credits: Haidyn Yerkovich

#86

Image credits: Kan Ye

#87

Image credits: Dave Diggler Roberts

#88

Image credits: Nick Dalby

#89

Image credits: Sharmayne Scott

#90

Image credits: Karen Commons

#91

Image credits: Caboo Jones

#92

Image credits: Julia Grace Lee

#93

Image credits: Stephanie Bernard Young

#94

Image credits: Megan Carr

#95

Image credits: Dave Diggler Roberts

#96

Image credits: Spencer Shore