Recently, one of the brightest Palestinian novelists, Abbad Yahiya, saw his fourth book, Crime in Ramallah, seized by the Palestinian police in the West Bank. The order came from Palestinian Attorney General Ahmed Barak, who ruled that the book "threatens morality". The novel's publisher was arrested and a warrant was issued for Yahiya's arrest.
When Palestinian novelist Abbad Yahiya recently published his fourth book, Crime in Ramallah, the Palestinian Authority police seized all copies the book, claiming it "threatens morality". The novel's publisher was arrested and a warrant was issued for Yahiya's arrest. (Image source: Wikimedia Commons)
His novel revolves around the murder of a Palestinian girl in Ramallah, and follows the lives of three other boys, from a homosexual to a drinker of alcohol. The novel takes aim at Palestinian taboos such as fanaticism, Islamic extremism and homosexuality. The young gay protagonist of the novel ends up moving to France.
"I do not know what to do", said Yahiya, who fled to Qatar. "If I return, I will be arrested".
The head of the Union of Palestinian Writers, Murad Sudani, attacked Yahiya and called for an exemplary punishment as happened with Boris Pasternak and other Soviet novelists. According to Sudani, Yahiya's novel "violates national and religious values". He went on to say that "my freedom as a writer ends when the freedom of the country begins". So Palestinian writers should behave like the Soviet "engineers of souls", then at the service of Communism, now of Islamic extremism and the Palestinian war against Israel.
Yahiya was also threatened on social media. Ghassan Khader, a Facebook user, wrote on his page that Yahiya "should be killed". Yahiya should apparently meet the same fate of the Algerian writer Tahar Djaout, murdered by Islamists in 1994. Yahiya's publisher, Fuad Akleek, was arrested in a library "in a very humiliating way". The Palestinian police are reported to have entered five hundred libraries and bookshops of the West Bank to seize all the copies of the novel.
Yahiya's fate is reminiscent of many others under the Palestinian Authority:
- Waleed al Husseini is a Palestinian blogger who has spent ten months in a Palestinian prison for the same "crime" as the one for which the Charlie Hebdo magazine's journalists were murdered: "Blasphemy". Like the gay man in Yahiya's novel, Waleed now lives in France, protected and blessed by Europe's freedom.
- Haidar Ghanem, the Palestinian human rights activist, was less lucky. He was shot to death by Islamic extremists.
- Mohammed Dajani, the Palestinian professor who took his students on a field trip to Auschwitz, had to resign to save his own life after months-long campaign of death threats, campus riots and intimidation. He broke the Palestinian taboo of Holocaust denial. "I put my job on the line to expose the double-talk we live", Dajani told Haaretz. "We say we are for democracy and we practice autocracy, we say we are for freedom of speech and academic freedom, yet we deny people to practice it".
- Many Palestinian Christian activists have also been found dead.
Famous Israeli writers such as David Grossman, Amos Oz and Abraham Yehoshua, the "peaceniks" most pampered by the Western newspapers, should, instead of blaming their own country, ask themselves what Abbad Yahiya's case means for the Arab-Israeli conflict, and if they should denounce the Palestinian Authority for what it is doing to him.
What happened to Yahiya's novel contains the real reason for the failed negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians. Negotiations did not founder over few houses in Judea and Samaria. The failure is the result of the abyss between an open society, Israel, and a closed regime, the Palestinian entity; between a democracy based on Western liberal principles and a gangster autocracy based on an Islamic dictatorship determined to destroy the Jewish state.
And that abyss is just four kilometers wide, the distance between the Palestinian town of Tulkarem and the Israeli city of Netanya.
A Palestinian State created with the current Palestinian Authority would ethnically cleanse Jews, as Jordan did when it attacked and seized Jerusalem in 1948.
It would be led by Holocaust-enablers such as Hamas, or by a Holocaust-denier such as Mahmoud Abbas. It would destroy freedom of conscience for journalists and writers; exile Christians and homosexuals (hundreds of Palestinian gays now live beyond Israel's security fence); torture Arab inmates; continue to accept funding from Iran and Sunni Islamic extremists in the name of "the caliphate or death"; impose sharia (Islamic law) as the only law; put people to death for "atheism" and "apostasy" (read, conversion to Christianity). It would most likely oblige women to wear burqas and hijabs as in Saudi Arabia; commemorate terrorists and baby-killers who butchered 1,500 Israeli civilians during the Second Intifada; abolish democratic elections; fill libraries with anti-Semitic and anti-Western books; ban alcohol in public, and ask plainclothes officers to stop young couples to show marriage licenses, as in Iran.
How would you describe that state, if not as a carbon copy of a Nazi government? And what is the only country that would allow the creation of such a state on its own shoulders? The world's only Jewish State? Of course.
Giulio Meotti, Cultural Editor for Il Foglio, is an Italian journalist and author.