Get Even More Visitors To Your Blog, Upgrade To A Business Listing >>

Major twist in legal battle over Charlie Gard, critically ill UK baby

  • Trending Videos CBSN Live »

  • CBSN


    Parents of Charlie Gard drop legal case


  • Newsmakers

    The Brothers Rosenberg


  • CBS This Morning

    Human trafficking tragedy


  • CBS This Morning

    Kushner: "I did not collude"


  • CBS This Morning

    Changing Trump's message


  • CBS This Morning

    Storms slam the midwest


  • CBS This Morning

    Officer properly trained?


  • CBS This Morning

    The abortion debate


  • CBS This Morning

    Princes remember Diana


  • CBS This Morning

    Florida family's search for justice


  • CBS This Morning

    Murder mystery unsolved


  • CBS This Morning

    What's next for O.J. Simpson?


  • CBS This Morning

    Diet may impact MS symptoms


  • CBS This Morning

    Workers make prehistoric discovery


  • CBS This Morning

    Linda Fairstein on "Deadfall"


  • CBS Evening News

    Scaramucci threatens action


  • CBS Evening News

    Dickerson on Scaramucci


  • CBS Evening News

    Bodies found inside truck


  • CBS Evening News

    Kentucky's abortion clinic


  • World

    Major twist in legal battle over critically ill baby Charlie Gard


  • World

    German girl found in ISIS hideout wants "to go home"


  • World

    Police hunt for chainsaw attacker after 5 wounded


  • World

    Car bomb attack targeting police kills at least 12


  • World

    Dozens killed in suicide car bomb attack


  • World

    Jordan Spieth wins 2017 British Open


  • World

    Jordanian killed, Israeli wounded in violent incident at Israeli embassy


  • World

    William, Harry remember devastating last call with mother


  • World

    American student arrested in China has been freed, senator says


  • World

    Swiss couple buried after missing in Swiss Alps for 75 years


  • World

    Taliban fighters seize 2 districts, kill police officers


  • World

    Branden Grace shoots 62 to break golf record

Last Updated Jul 24, 2017 3:19 PM EDT

LONDON — The parents of Charlie Gard, whose battle to get their critically ill baby experimental treatment stirred international sympathy and controversy, dropped their legal effort Monday, saying tearfully that it was time to let their son die.

At an emotional court hearing, a lawyer for the baby's parents, Chris Gard and Connie Yates, said the couple was withdrawing a bid to have Charlie sent to the United States, where a doctor had offered to try to treat his rare genetic condition. The decision came after new medical tests showed Charlie, who has brain damage and cannot breathe unaided, had irreversible muscular damage.

CBS News correspondent Jane Ferguson reports the parents' decision was unexpected. Monday's proceedings were expected to include impassioned arguments in favor of taking Charlie to the U.S. and counterarguments from doctors who had said nothing could be done for him. A verdict in the case wasn't expected until Tuesday.

Both parents wept in the packed courtroom at the High Court in London as lawyer Grant Armstrong made the announcement, his voice breaking.

Play
Video

Video

Parents of critically ill U.K. baby withdraw request for U.S. treatment

The parents of Charlie Gard have dropped a months-long plea for their son to receive experimental treatment in the United States.

"This case is now about time," Armstrong said. "Sadly, time has run out."

Outside court, Chris Gard said that Charlie "won't make his first birthday in just under two weeks' time."

"We are about to do the hardest thing that we will ever have to do, which is to let our beautiful little Charlie go," he said.

Gard and Yates, who are in their 30s and from London, have fought ferociously for their son, who was born in August 2016 with mitochondrial depletion syndrome, a rare genetic disease.

The baby has been treated at Great Ormond Street Hospital in London, one of the world's leading children's hospitals. Doctors there say Charlie is in pain and further treatment would only increase his suffering. They have sought permission from the courts to switch off his life support and allow him to die peacefully. His parents have resisted, arguing that an experimental treatment could extend and improve Charlie's life.

The case gained international attention after Charlie's parents received support from Pope Francis, President Trump and some members of the U.S. Congress.

On Monday, the Vatican said Francis was praying for Charlie and his parents, and urged the faithful to join him in prayer so that the baby's parents "may find God's consolation and love."

As the legal battle dragged on, U.S.-based pro-life activists had flown to London to support Charlie's parents, and the case became a flashpoint for opposing views on health-care funding, medical intervention, the role of the state and the rights of the child.

Connie Yates with her son Charlie Gard

Passions have often run high, with activists demanding "justice for Charlie" rallying outside the High Court and Great Ormond Street Hospital. Over the weekend, the hospital said it had contacted police after staff received abuse and threats.

Charlie's parents condemned the abuse, and on Monday thanked the hospital for the care it had given their child.

Some commentators portrayed the case as a clash between family and the state, and U.S. conservatives used it to criticize Britain's government-funded health care system – even though the case was never about money.

Judge Nicholas Francis criticized those "who know almost nothing about this case but who feel entitled to express opinions."

At its heart, the case pitted the right of parents to decide what's best for their children against the authorities' responsibility to uphold the rights of people who can't speak for themselves.

Under British law, children have rights independent of their parents, and it is usual for courts to intervene when parents and doctors disagree on the treatment of a child – such as cases where a parent's religious beliefs prohibit blood transfusions.

British courts and the European Court of Human Rights all ruled against Charlie's parents and in favor of Great Ormond Street. The case returned to court this month when the hospital asked the judge to reassess the possible benefits of a treatment pioneered by Dr. Michio Hirano, a neurology expert from Columbia Medical Center in New York.

Undated photo of Charlie Gard provided by his family, at Great Ormond Street Hospital, in London.

At a hearing earlier this month, Hirano said there was a 10 percent chance of a significant improvement in Charlie's muscle use with the treatment, known as nucleoside therapy. But he conceded it had never been tried on humans, or even on mice with Charlie's exact condition.

Hirano came to London last week to examine Charlie along with other experts. After seeing the results of new tests, the baby's parents agreed to drop their case, meaning Charlie's life support can now be removed.

But they still believe Charlie could have been saved had months not been spent in legal wrangling about whether he should get treatment.

"Had Charlie been given the treatment sooner he would have had the potential to be a normal, healthy little boy," Yates told the court.

"Our son has an extremely rare disease for which there is no accepted cure, but that does not mean that this treatment would not have worked, and it certainly does not mean that this shouldn't have been tried."

The hospital disagreed. Its lawyer, Katie Gollop, said Charlie had suffered "irreversible neurological damage" and the treatment would have been "futile." She said the hospital stood by its belief that Charlie was in pain.

"At the first hearing in Charlie's case in March, (Great Ormond Street Hospital's) position was that every day that passed was a day that was not in his best interests," Gollop said in a written statement. "That remains its view of his welfare."

The hospital also criticized Hirano, saying that he had given evidence to court without having read previous judgments or Charlie's medical records. And it noted that Hirano had told the court that he "retains a financial interest in some of the … compounds he proposed prescribing for Charlie."

Ending a case he called tragic for all involved, the judge paid tribute to Charlie's parents, saying it was impossible to comprehend the agony they faced.

"No parent could have done more for their child," he said.

Yates cried as she told the court she and Charlie's father had only wanted the best for their son.

"We are so sorry that we couldn't save you," she said.

© 2017 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

    Featured in World


    • Ex-hedge fund manager founds school in Somaliland

      Jonathan Starr tells "60 Minutes" that when he founded a school in struggling Somaliland, he gave students a “chance to win” and that’s exactly what they did


    • The Family: Stories from inside the cult led by self-proclaimed mystic Anne Hamilton-Byrne

      Allegations of stolen children, drugs, abuse and a leader who claimed to be the second coming of Jesus Christ — "48 Hours" follows the trail of a cult that began in Australia and led the FBI to New York

    Popular

    CBSN Live

    pop-out

    From 60 Minutes


    • My favorite "60 Minutes" story


    • Sons of Cold War spies reinvestigate parents' case


    • Ex-Gov. Bob McDonnell on SCOTUS overturning his conviction


    • Why Bob McDonnell talked to "60 Minutes"


    • Should the U.S. government pay ransom money?

    • Play
      Video

      Linda Fairstein on "Deadfall"

    • Play
      Video

      Workers make prehistoric discovery

    • Play
      Video

      What's next for O.J. Simpson?

    • Play
      Video

      Whales in NYC

    • Play
      Video

      Marines return to Helmand

    • Play
      Video

      Western wildfires

    Previous

    Next

    • 43
      Photos

      Music, mud and marriage at Country Thunder 2017

    • 32
      Photos

      John Heard 1945-2017

    • 64
      Photos

      O.J. Simpson then and now

    • 55
      Photos

      Cosplay at San Diego Comic-Con

    • 59
      Photos

      Western wildfires

    Previous

    Next

    Most Discussed


    • Why Bob McDonnell talked to 60 Minutes


    • Sneak peek: The Mortician, The Murder, The Movie


    • How Jack Black relates to the convicted killer he plays in the film "Bernie"


    • The August solar eclipse on your smartphone


    • Docs: Truck driver said he didn't know people were inside

    New Fire TV App


      The post Major twist in legal battle over Charlie Gard, critically ill UK baby appeared first on Shareabler - Shareable Stories.



      This post first appeared on Shareabler, please read the originial post: here

      Share the post

      Major twist in legal battle over Charlie Gard, critically ill UK baby

      ×

      Subscribe to Shareabler

      Get updates delivered right to your inbox!

      Thank you for your subscription

      ×