So, first I melt the makeup and/or SPF product with an oil-based cleanser.
I have tried several cleansing oils, and find some very heavy. They rinse off fine, but massaging them into my skin feels like a lot of work and leaves my skin reddened. I like DHC's Gentle Touch cleansing oil very much, but it's hard to find in stores. MAC's version is fragrance-free and is available at Ulta, MAC stores, department stores, etc.
To make sure I've removed every bit of makeup, I follow with this foaming cleanser. It's a low-pH, unscented cleanser that produces a lovely, soft cushiony foam and rinses clean, leaving my skin clean but not stripped. I've found it on Amazon, eBay, and Sally Beauty. It's dirt cheap and lasts forever, because you only need a pea-sized dab of it.
Once or twice a week I use my trusty ancient Clarisonic Mia. I'm a huge fan of chemical exfoliants (which I'll discuss in another post) but nothing is easier and more cost effective than a physical exfoliator. I tend to use it in the shower so I can use it on my neck and upper chest without spraying water all over my bathroom.
That's it. I keep a bottle of Bioderma micellar water around, mostly for freshening up my face in the morning. And I find that I don't use eye makeup removers; the cleansing oil takes care of that for me.
OMG how did I become such a minimalist????