Differences between Indian Government and U.S. Government - Indian Polity
India is the largest democracy in the world, whereas the United States of America is the oldest democracy. Although both countries are democratic republics, there are some differences in the way both governments function. UPSC aspirants should be aware of the basic differences between the two governments. In this article, you can read about the differences between Indian and US governments, which is a part of polity in the UPSC syllabus.
Differences between the Governments of India and the USA
The differences between both the governments are given under separate headings.
Political Parties
| India | USA |
| Although there are currently 2 major national parties – the INC and the BJP; there are hundreds of regional and smaller parties in the political scene. | There are two major political parties here. They are the Republican Party and the Democratic Party. |
Head of State
| India | USA |
- Elected head of Government is the Prime Minister. He is the executive head.
- The President is the constitutional head of state.
- Citizens cast their vote to elect their representatives to the Lok Sabha. The party that wins a majority of seats in the Lok Sabha gets invited by the President to form the government.
- The leader of that party becomes the Prime Minister.
- Elections to the Lok Sabha are held every five years generally.
| - Head of State is the President.
- Citizens cast their ballot in every state to elect members of the electoral college (popular vote) who in turn cast electoral votes to determine the President.
- The President holds office for a four-year term.
|
Government
| India | USA |
- The government can lose the mandate if its majority cannot be proved in the Lok Sabha in the event of a no-confidence motion.
- This would lead to mid-term elections.
- Parliamentary form of government.
| - The President is not dependent on the strength of his party in Congress (legislative body).
- He remains in power for the four years of his term unless he is impeached or incapacitated.
- Presidential form of government.
|
Cabinet
| India | USA |
- The Prime Minister appoints members of his cabinet from his party or from those supporting his coalition (if it’s a coalition government).
| - President nominates cabinet members and sends them to the Senate for confirmation.
- The cabinet members need not be Congress members, they could just be industry experts.
|
Legislative Body
| India | USA |
- The Parliament is the supreme legislative body.
- It is a bicameral legislature comprising of the President, the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.
- Lok Sabha (House of the People) members are elected directly by the people. There are 545 members.
- Rajya Sabha (Council of States) members are elected by the State legislative assemblies. Its total membership is 245.
| - Congress is the legislature of the USA.
- The Senate and the House of Representatives are the two chambers of the Congress
- The House of Representatives (commonly referred to as the House) is the Lower House while the Senate is the Upper House.
|
Legislation authority
| India | USA |
- There is no strict separation of powers.
- The executive is part of the elected legislature and remains in power while the House is in motion.
- The Prime Minister cannot override the legislature to make laws.
- A bill becomes a law only when both Houses pass it and it is signed by the President.
- The president can send any bill back to the parliament for consideration if he deems fit. But if it’s passed again, he should sign it.
- The SC can strike down any law that it considers unconstitutional.
| - Here, there is a clear separation of powers between the executive, the legislature and the judiciary.
- A law passed by the Congress can be vetoed by the President.
- He can send it back for consideration, or he can also bypass the Congress and issue an executive order (which has the force of law).
- However, Congress can override the veto by obtaining a 2/3rd majority in both Houses.
|
Federalism
| India | USA |
- India can be said to be a case of cooperative federalism.
- There is only one constitution for the whole country.
- India is neither purely federal nor purely unitary.
- It is a federal structure with a strong unitary bias.
- India is a union of states meaning states have no authority to recede from India.
| - It has a federal system with each state having its own constitution.
- Here, power is shared between the federal government and state governments.
|
