The U.S. Constitution contains very Few Provisions relating to the Qualifications of Presidential Electors. Article II, section 1, clause 2 provides that No Senator, Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the U.S. shall be Appointed an Elector. As a Historical matter, the 14th Amendment provides that State Officials who have Engaged in Insurrection or Rebellion against the U.S. or given Aid and Comfort to its Enemies are Disqualified from serving as Electors. This Prohibition relates to the Post-Civil War Era.
The National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) has compiled a brief Summary of State Laws about the various Procedures, which vary from State to State, for Selecting Slates of Potential Electors and for Conducting the Meeting of the Electors.
Each State's Certificates of Ascertainment Confirms the Names of its Appointed Electors. A State's Certification of its Electors is generally sufficient to establish the Qualifications of Electors.
Choosing each State's Electors is a Two-Part Process: First, the Political Parties in Many States choose Slates of potential Presidential Electors sometime before the General Election. Second, on Election Day, the Voters in each State select their State's Electors by Casting their Ballots for President or can also Select the Electors.
The First Part of the Process is Controlled by the Political Parties in each State and varies from State to State. Generally, the Parties either Nominate Slates of Potential Electors at their State Party Conventions or they Chose them by a Vote of the Party's Central Committee. This happens in each State for each Party by whatever Rules the State Party, and sometimes, the National Party have for the Process. This First part of the Process results in each Presidential Candidate having their Own Unique Slate of Potential Electors.
Political Parties often Choose Electors for the Slate to Recognize their Service and Dedication to that Political Party. They may be State Elected Officials, State Party Leaders, or People in the State who have a Personal or Political Affiliation with their Party's Presidential Candidate.
The Second Part of the Process happens on Election Day. When the Voters in each State Cast Votes for the Presidential Candidate of their choice they are Voting to Select their State's Electors. The Potential Electors' Names may or may Not Appear on the Ballot below the Name of the Presidential Candidates, depending on Election Procedures and Ballot Formats in each State.
The Winning Presidential Candidate's Slate of Potential Electors are Appointed as the State's Electors, except in Nebraska and Maine, which have Proportional Distribution of the Electors. In Nebraska and Maine, the State Winner receives Two Electors and the Winner of each Congressional District, who may be the Same as the Overall Winner or a Different Candidate, receives One Elector. This System permits the Electors from Nebraska and Maine to be Awarded to more than One Candidate.
Current, there is No Constitutional Provision or Federal Law that requires Electors to Vote according to the Results of the Popular Vote in their States. Some states, however, require Electors to Cast their Votes according to the State Popular Vote. These Pledges fall into Two Categories: Electors bound by State Law and those Bound by Pledges to Political Parties.
The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the Constitution does Not Require that Electors be completely Free to Act as they Choose and therefore, Political Parties may Extract Pledges from Electors to Vote for the Parties' Nominees. Some State Laws provide that so-called "Faithless Electors" may be Subject to Fines or may be Disqualified for Casting an Invalid Vote and be Replaced by a Substitute Elector. The Supreme Court has Not Specifically Ruled on the Question of whether Pledges and Penalties for Failure to Vote as Pledged may be Enforced under the Constitution.
NYC Wins When Everyone Can Vote! Michael H. Drucker