Get Even More Visitors To Your Blog, Upgrade To A Business Listing >>

How can I reply to peer review comments requesting additional experiments?

Question Description: 

I submitted one Paper to a journal a few months ago. Now I have received the second round of reviewer comments. One reviewer said, "It could be informative to add some stainings of integrin signaling like P-FAK or P-Src and/or TGFb signaling (P-Smad)" Should I add more experiments? My paper topic is about the relationship between one molecular and tissue hardness. It's nothing to do with integrin signaling. If I add some stainings, it means I need to revise paper extensively. Do you think I should conduct the experiment and add in the paper? Is there any other way to respond to the reviewer? Thank you! 

Answer

Reviewer comments are basically suggestions to improve your manuscript. Whether you incorporate the suggestions and to what extent depends on you. If you strongly disagree with a specific suggestion, you can always choose not to make the suggested change, explaining your reasons for disagreement.

In the case of this request to conduct an additional experiment, do not think about the rework it will involve. Consider whether it will improve the manuscript substantially. You should conduct the experiment only if you feel it will add value to your paper. If you feel it is not relevant and/or will change the focus of your paper, you should not do it. 

If you choose not to conduct the experiment, you should explain in your response document that you disagree with this point. Explain why you disagree, backing your argument with strong reasoning or supporting evidence. Make sure your tone is very polite. At the end of the response letter, mention that you are willing to make further changes if required.

Recommended reading:

  • How should I respond if I cannot address a reviewer's suggestion?
  • What can I do when I can't agree with the reviewer's comments?

Share the post

How can I reply to peer review comments requesting additional experiments?

×

Subscribe to Educational Resources For Researchers, Authors, Journals On Academic Research, Manuscript Writing, Editing, Proofreading, And Journal Publishing

Get updates delivered right to your inbox!

Thank you for your subscription

×