What is it about Family that can be so frustrating, difficult, even infuriating? My mom sometimes reminiscences about how patient, how obedient, how “good” I used to be, wonders what changed. I tell her it’s because I’m not a child. I have thoughts and beliefs of my own, draw upon experiences and knowledge that I have acquired. And because I no longer take what she says at face value, because she no longer thinks on my behalf, I appear more disobedient in her eyes.
I wonder though if there’s more to it than that, than my growing up.
I have this image of myself as a person, an image of who I am and who I aspire to be. There’s a bit of embellishment, naturally, a bit of it skewed favorably on my behalf. I imagine that is the case with all of us. We have this slightly idealized image of ourselves, of how we present ourselves to the world. And with family, I think, their vision of us – and for us – is every bit as fleshed out, as real and fully-formed and stubborn, as our own.
My third or fourth grade class hosted open house. On my featured piece of art, my family noticed I signed my birthyear instead of the current year, and they teased me about it. I felt embarrassed and I got mad. It was so demoralizing to lose control of the situation, to be painted as this mistake-prone goof, then a ill-tempered brat.
These two images of the self – the one we envision, the one envisioned by family – are not altogether independent nor irreconcilable, of course. But I think the external image held by family appears to them as more true because of its basis in history, whereas our internal self appears to them only as a tiny slice of what they believe to be true. In other words, the image we cultivate and present to the world is inevitably, constantly, and fundamentally challenged by family.
But how well do they know us, really? I’ve seen my family about three or four times in the last four years. They don’t really understand what I do, workwise. And they’ve met some friends, fleetingly. Our daily realities are just so far apart, and not only geographically.
The dynamic works both ways. There’s a reason why we prep ourselves before spending extended time with family. We anticipate what is to come, because we too have fostered an image of who and what they are. We too fit their present self into a far greater narrative of what we “know” them to be – interacting on multiple levels, across myriad moments. And because of this, we not only confirm our vision and our narrative but project them.
In my junior year of high school, I received disappointing scores for my retaken Scholastic Aptitude Test. I got home and told my mom, and her face said enough. Before she verbally reacted, I left and drove for hours, going nowhere, avoiding confrontation. It was the environment she had fostered. …Asian parents.
There’s more to it though. The relationship between the images, which interact and play off one another. The fact that we can have so little in common yet still retain an elemental, intangible bond in which family appears almost as a reflection of our own self. The effect of seeing in someone the traits that are so familiar to what we see in ourselves – good and bad, only far more exaggerated, or at least far more obvious… to us.
One Christmas, short on ideas, I found a little holiday gift pack for my sister: a stuffed penguin, hot chocolate mix, and marshmallows. Completely independent of me, she – needing a gift for an exchange at her friend’s party that year – somehow ended up buying that very same pack at the very same department store.
Family thus forces us to reflect. Even if we acknowledge the biased lens through which we see ourselves, we look and make ourselves out to be an improved specimen, a 2.0. Because to see any alternative suggests something far worse – a hypocrisy in which we can see the flaws in those who reflect ourselves the most (even if in an elemental, intangible manner) and yet choose not to address them, turning our backs to self-betterment.
My mom’s martyrdom, her hard-headedness, her pettiness and long-memory, her judgmental nature and fear of so many things and self-doubt and need for validation. The way she sees love, the way she has to be all-in. All of that is me.
It feels odd, the whole of it. Perhaps the lack of choice exacerbates the frustrating, infuriating moments, with an undercurrent of feeling that we cannot be comforted, let alone rescued, by the simple recognition of agency, of effort, of desire – as we might with such moments in the context of friendships or partnerships. In contrast, family, in all but the most extreme situation, exists unquestioned and unchallenged.
A good friend made fun of me harshly because I thought that Finding Forrester was non-fiction. He was tactless; I was embarrassed.* I went off to the movie theater bathroom to get some space. But then I had to drive him home. That’s the best analogy I have for family. We’re stuck in the car, always.
*It is kind of funny to look back on these things that I thought mattered so much in the moment.
So we question and challenge by other means. We make less effort to suppress our frustration. We act more pettily, brushing aside the image of the self they present and imposing the grand narrative over them – their every action thus a confirmation of what we already know to be true. We push a little harder understanding that there is an element of non-choice to the matter. We take family for granted.
Then again, I don’t have a relationship with my dad, so I guess family can be a choice too.
Family is difficult. It seems to get moreso. But maybe that’s just me.